Steven Moffat’s Superior “Final” Doctor Who Episode Released Just 7 Months Prior

Steven Moffat is among a select group of three showrunners who have guided Doctor Who since its revival in 2005. However, with the release of “Joy to the World”in 2024, many critics argue that this episode doesn’t quite encapsulate his finest work. The beloved sci-fi series first premiered in 1963, boasting a rich legacy that extends over 60 years, during which numerous writers have left their imprint. Yet, in the modern era, only three showrunners have significantly influenced the direction of the series over the past two decades.

Russell T Davies first revived the show in 2005, collaborating with trusted associates to resurrect Doctor Who from obscurity, ultimately transforming it into a cultural phenomenon in the UK. Following RTD, Steven Moffat, who previously worked alongside him during the revival, assumed the role of showrunner. His dual success with Doctor Who and Sherlock elevated the series to unprecedented heights. Now, with the returning Russell T Davies helming the show after a stint from Christopher Chibnall, Moffat is back to contribute once again to this iconic narrative.

“Boom”Provides a Fitting Farewell for Moffat, Unlike “Joy to the World”

“Boom”Presents a Stronger Narrative Structure

Steven Moffat stands out as a remarkable storyteller, renowned for crafting spellbinding episodes within the expansive Doctor Who universe. Notably, he introduced memorable villains like the Weeping Angels and The Silence, while also exploring the complex narrative of the Doctor’s many deaths. Moffat’s storytelling prowess shines through his ability to create impactful narratives that often do not rely on elaborate settings or extensive effects.

In his recent contribution, “Boom,”featured in Ncuti Gatwa’s debut season, Moffat masterfully illustrates this talent. The entire plot centers on a poignant scenario where the Doctor must remain motionless on a landmine to prevent catastrophic destruction, risking the lives of innocent nearby soldiers and refugees. This emotionally charged, straightforward narrative serves as a powerful, fittingly resonant moment for Moffat as he potentially exits the series on a high note.

“Joy to the World”: Moffat’s Swansong?

“Joy to the World”Shines as a Holiday Special

Ncuti Gatwa and Nicola Coughlan in Doctor Who

The Doctor in Doctor Who Christmas Special

Moffat has the distinction of writing the highest number of holiday specials in Doctor Who’s history. Even after stepping down as showrunner—which transitioned to Chris Chibnall—Moffat returned to pen “Twice Upon A Time,”contributing to the farewell of the Twelfth Doctor before the arrival of Jodie Whittaker. With “Joy to the World,”Moffat carries on his legacy, yet many fans feel it lacks the poignancy of “Boom”as a final chapter.

Showrunner	Number of Specials
Russell T Davies	7
Steven Moffat	9
Chris Chibnall	4

While “Boom”connects seamlessly with the rest of its season—featuring a character who is integral to the Doctor’s new companion—it’s important to note that holiday specials like “Joy to the World”tend to diverge from the central narrative arcs of the regular series. Nevertheless, it showcases Moffat’s exceptional ability to transform ordinary moments into compelling storytelling. As of yet, there’s no definitive statement confirming Moffat’s departure from Doctor Who.

Will Moffat Remain Involved with Doctor Who?

Moffat’s Continued Involvement Seems Likely

Although Moffat distanced himself from the series during Chibnall’s tenure, he has eagerly returned to write scripts following RTD’s return. Having already penned two episodes in the latest season, it seems that he is enthusiastic about contributing again. The shift from showrunner to writer appears to afford him a renewed sense of creative freedom while balancing other projects.

While “Joy to the World”may be perceived as Moffat’s last contribution, his proactive engagement in promotional activities and press suggests that his involvement may continue. Ultimately, it seems improbable that Steven Moffat will step away from Doctor Who for an extended period, given the welcome he receives from current showrunners.

Source & Images