Stranger Things Season 5 Needs to Defy Character Death Patterns Established in the First Four Seasons

To deliver a fulfilling conclusion to the saga of Hawkins, Stranger Things will need to challenge an emerging trend in its storytelling. Since its inception in 2016, the Duffer Brothers have captivated audiences with memorable characters and an engaging narrative that pays homage to the 1980s. Yet, despite its success, fans have begun to express dissatisfaction with a recurring theme: the reluctance to kill off major characters. With the upcoming fifth season, expected in 2025, there’s a critical expectation to address this concern and raise the stakes.

As the plot thickens and tension escalates for Hawkins’ defenders, the impact of Vecna (portrayed by Jamie Campbell Bower) is becoming increasingly apparent. Over the past eight years, it has become evident that the Duffer Brothers have avoided eliminating any established lead characters. Conflicts arise but seldom result in fatal consequences, fostering a perception that the protagonists exist in a protective bubble. This trend not only diminishes the feeling of peril but also amplifies audience anticipation for a more impactful finale.

Historical Character Deaths in Stranger Things

The Tragic Fate of Supporting Characters

Stranger Things has a history of showcasing the peril faced by supporting characters. The inaugural season opened with the poignant death of Barb (Shannon Purser), which served to establish the serious threats posed by the Upside Down. This tragic narrative continued with the death of Bob (Sean Astin) in season two, which sparked significant backlash from viewers who were devastated by his demise, particularly as he met a cruel fate just as he managed to escape danger.

Character Name	Episode of Death
Benny Hammond	Season 1, Episode 1
Barbara Holland	Season 1, Episode 2
Connie Frazier	Season 1, Episode 8
Bob Newby	Season 2, Episode 8
Heather Holloway	Season 3, Episode 6
Dr. Alexei	Season 3, Episode 7
Grigori	Season 3, Episode 8
Billy Hargrove	Season 3, Episode 8
Chrissy Cunningham	Season 4, Episode 1
Fred Benson	Season 4, Episode 3
Agent Harmon	Season 4, Episode 4
Patrick McKinney	Season 4, Episode 4
Virginia and Alice Creel	Season 4, Episode 7
(Almost) Everyone at Hawkins Lab	Season 4, Episode 7
Dr. Brenner	Season 4, Episode 8
Eddie Munson	Season 4, Episode 9
Jason Carver	Season 4, Episode 9

The latter seasons have become notorious for their misleading death scenes, often leading to disappointment among viewers. While the deaths of characters like Billy (Dacre Montgomery) and Eddie (Joseph Quinn) delivered emotional impact, they fell short of resonating with the main storyline. In order to maintain narrative integrity in season five, it is crucial that significant risks be posed to lead characters.

The Need for Main Character Deaths in Season 5

A Bold Finale Calls for Realistic Sacrifices

Max at Billy's Grave — Max confronting loss at Billy’s grave.

As Stranger Things approaches its final season, the stakes must reflect the dangers awaiting Hawkins. The series has demonstrated through its narrative that sacrifice is intrinsic to heroism. It would be a disservice to ignore the potential fallout of ongoing threats. If the show continues to protect its main characters, the final confrontation will likely lack the emotional weight fans have been anticipating.

With Vecna presenting a more formidable threat than before, the emotional undercurrents of the story demand that at least one significant character must perish to echo the intensity of the previous seasons. The unresolved fate of Max (Sadie Sink) at the end of season four exemplifies the looming danger posed by Vecna and the narrative necessity for bold decisions in the concluding arcs.

Ultimately, neglecting to follow through with real sacrifices amidst the high stakes would undermine audience engagement and lead to a lackluster finale. Fans eagerly await to see who might meet their end in what promises to be an explosive season finale of Stranger Things.

Source & Images