Superstore Reunion: Excitement and Risks for St. Denis’ Future Success

St. Denis Medical has gained traction as a standout comedy for NBC; however, its connection to the much-loved series Superstore could hinder its progress. Both shows are the brainchildren of Justin Spitzer, with Eric Ledgin also contributing to the modern sitcom landscape. While the characters in St. Denis Medical are undoubtedly talented, some actors are so closely associated with their previous roles that it presents a significant challenge. The presence of recognizable actors may undermine the unique identity St. Denis Medical strives to establish in the competitive landscape of workplace comedies.

The similarities between the two shows create an interesting dynamic for Superstore enthusiasts, yet they risk branding St. Denis Medical as merely a replacement for its predecessor. This association can confine the medical comedy to forever existing in Superstore‘s shadow. As we await the confirmation of a second season for St. Denis Medical, the remaining episodes of its inaugural season are crucial for demonstrating that it can stand independently of Spitzer’s earlier work.

Challenges in Establishing Identity Against the Superstore Legacy

Separating Actors from Their Superstore Identities

St. Denis Medical has infused its casting with alumni from Superstore, ranging from main characters to featured guest roles. Actors like Josh Lawson, who plays the confident yet arrogant doctor Bruce, present unique personalities, yet familiarities persist. Kaliko Kauahi’s portrayal of Val, while distinct, often elicits comparisons to her previous role as Sandra, leaving casual viewers reminiscing about her past character. Similarly, Nico Santos’s transition from Mateo to Rene in St. Denis Medical struggles under the weight of his iconic former role, which continues to overshadow his new narrative even years after Superstore concluded.

While St. Denis Medical airs Tuesdays at 8 PM ET on NBC and is available for streaming on Peacock the following day, past comedy giant Superstore can be found on Hulu. The challenge lies beyond viewer nostalgia; unfair comparisons serve to dilute the original appeal of the new comedy. It is inherently flawed to measure a fresh show against a beloved completed series. The tight linkage between the two shows inhibits viewers from fully embracing the uniqueness of St. Denis Medical. Critics have pointed out that the similarities create a perception that St. Denis Medical lacks certain elements that made Superstore resonate so effectively with audiences.

Strategies for St. Denis Medical to Break Free from the Superstore Comparison

Strategies for Creating Distinct Characters

Doctors of St. Denis Medical dancing in the hallway

For St. Denis Medical to carve out its own niche away from the shadows of Superstore, it must prioritize the distinctiveness of its characters. The struggle of audiences recognizing actors from past successes is widespread, yet St. Denis Medical needs to counterbalance that challenge effectively. Although viewers might remember Matt (Mekki Leeper) from Jury Duty or identify Wendi McLendon-Covey with her character from The Goldbergs, the individual portrayals of characters like Joyce—the hospital director—and Matt, who embodies the rookie spirit, quickly evolved into unique identities. Sadly, many of the actors from Superstore have yet to be granted the same richness in development.

Bruce stands as the closest attempt by St. Denis Medical to differentiate itself; however, his character functions similarly to Tate from Superstore, embodying the role of a lovable narcissist. The series needs to invest more time in uncovering the different facets of its characters. It’s essential for characters like Val to demonstrate deeper dimensions, for Bruce’s boastful exterior to reveal vulnerabilities, and for Rene to gain greater visibility in the narrative. At its core, St. Denis Medical is a sitcom that merits appreciation, but this journey begins with showcasing the full complexity of its characters.

St. Denis Medical continues its journey on Tuesdays at 8 PM ET on NBC.

Source & Images