The Boys Offers a Unique Perspective on Supervillains, Yet Its Lore Remains Underutilized

The distinct charm of The Boys lies in its bold defiance of conventional superhero conventions. In a landscape saturated with superhero narratives, audiences are increasingly looking for fresh perspectives and daring interpretations of these fantastical realms. Garth Ennis, Darick Robertson, and Russ Braun’s comic series, The Boys, masterfully fulfills this desire by delivering a subversive twist that both entertains and provokes thought.

At the heart of The Boys is a playful critique of the archetypal superhero, who is often viewed as a noble figure fighting against malevolence. This storyline intriguingly reframes this concept, highlighting the moral decay and corruption that these so-called heroes encounter in their pursuit of justice.

Comic book panel: Homelander begins a meeting of the Seven at Vought

Yet, there exists a richer dimension beneath this primary theme: an incisive examination of the supervillain’s role within the superhero genre. This alternate view mirrors the “hero gone rogue”narrative but offers an engaging, if underexplored, perspective that adds depth to the enticingly irreverent plot.

In The Boys, What’s Wrong Is Right, and What’s Right Is Wrong

Nothing Is As It Seems in The Boys‘ Hero-Villain Divide

Comic book art: Homelander yells shut up and breaks eardrums on airplane in The Boys comic

Traditional superhero narratives often affirm that superheroes exist to thwart supervillains—those malicious individuals whose considerable resources enable them to easily outmatch ordinary law enforcement. This draws upon the assumption that supervillains are inherently criminal, defined by their readiness to enact harm for personal advantage. In the context of this genre, the term “super”indicates a level of villainy that societal norms rarely encounter.

Inspired by the original works of Ennis, Robertson, and Braun, the The Boys television adaptation, now available on Amazon Prime, mirrors this complexity. Staying true to its subversive ethos, the series prominently features superheroes while ingeniously flipping the script on the notion of supervillainy. Rather than presenting a typical evildoer, the so-called “supervillains”are actually superheroes. These heroes are not malicious; instead, they are well-meaning individuals committed to saving the world, akin to more traditional figures like Superman or Spider-Man. However, their unyielding quest for justice inevitably brings them into conflict with Vought, the corporation responsible for their abilities. This nuanced depiction blurs the lines between who the true heroes and villains really are.

When these super-powered individuals choose to bypass the corporate directives and act independently, repercussions ensue. In a standard corporate environment, these might manifest as fines, suspensions, or even terminations. However, in the realm of Vought employees endowed with superpowers, these situations become far more complicated. Enter the Seven: Vought’s elite team of superpowered individuals, wholly committed to the mantra, “Keep Vought Great Forever,” and eager to ensure their agenda is fulfilled, no matter the cost.

The Boys’ Take on Corporate Superheroes Holds Boundless Potential

There’s Real-Life Meaning in This Superhero Narrative

The Boys Season 4 Homelander and the Seven

Influenced by Vought’s pervasive authority, any insubordinate supe employees are quickly branded “supervillains”by the media, a label that would resonate as “fake news”to any true villain. In contrast, the superheroes tasked with reining in these errant employees—the Seven—are glorified as paragons of virtue, even though their primary role is that of corporate security personnel. Notably, the Seven carry a far greater commitment to the Vought system. Above all, their focus is distinctly detached from the pursuit of truth, justice, and public welfare.

This plotline introduces an engaging twist where well-meaning heroes are vilified for defying corporate mandates, while the Seven, despite their superhero titles, act as corporate enforcers. For comic book enthusiasts, nothing is more riveting than a narrative where the concept of “superhero”becomes a mere facade created by a profit-driven corporation. Vought’s control of superhero narratives exemplifies how real-world businesses craft stories to preserve their market position.

Despite Its Radical Original Idea, The Boys Reverts to Familiar Tropes

When Supes Are Hunted Like Villains, What’s a Superhero to Do?

However, in its pursuit of thought-provoking storytelling, The Boys eventually falls back into the well-worn trope of absolute power corrupting even the most virtuous heroes. As the narrative progresses, despite an initial promise of a more complex examination of supervillains as rebellious figures, the focus increasingly shifts to the Seven and their corrupt behaviors, prioritizing accountability over the richer complexities of villainy.

This narrative pivot doesn’t detract from the brilliance of The Boys but rather represents a missed opportunity to deliver more powerful critiques of the superhero genre. Given Ennis and Robertson’s foundation aimed at redefining supervillains, the turn towards standard narrative constructs feels disheartening. By reverting to traditional tropes, The Boys undercuts its potential for incisive social commentary.

The Boys comic series is currently available from Dynamite.

Source & Images