The Boys Season 5 Finale Predicted to Be a Bloodbath, But One Character Must Survive

As the much-anticipated Season 5 of The Boys approaches, it is clear the show’s writers are poised for a dramatic and brutal conclusion. Given the series’ penchant for shocking character deaths—such as Victoria Neuman, Lamplighter, and Hugh Campbell Sr.—viewers can expect this final season to uphold its reputation for chaos and carnage. The source material, developed from Garth Ennis’s original comic series, has long foreshadowed a bloody finale, raising the stakes for all involved.

The turbulent ending of Season 4 has set an ominous tone for the future. With Homelander having established a dangerous regime in the United States and Billy Butcher bearing the deadly supe-killing virus, tensions are palpable. The prospect of heavy casualties weighs heavily on both the heroes and the villains as they navigate this perilous landscape.

(Almost) No Character is Safe in The Boys Season 5

The Boys Has Set Up Many Potential Casualties

Karen Fukuhara as Kimiko at a protest in The Boys.

Despite the history of character eliminations, it is notable that many central figures have managed to survive thus far. The main characters from The Boys and the pivotal members of The Seven—including Homelander, The Deep, A-Train, Queen Maeve, and Starlight—remain in the game. Interestingly, even the seemingly definitive death of Black Noir turned out to be a ruse, with the original actor reprising his role. Yet, the stakes feel particularly high for actors Antony Starr and Karl Urban, whose characters face imminent danger.

There is a growing sentiment that The Boys is saving its significant character deaths for its climactic conclusion, reminiscent of the dramatic end noted in the comic books. As fans ponder the fates that could befall the ensemble cast, it isn’t unreasonable to consider that the final season may leave viewers reeling—especially if many, if not all, end up meeting gruesome ends.

The certainty of a concluding season affords Eric Kripke and his team the liberty to delve into impactful character deaths without concern for future seasons. This focus on a defined ending allows for meaningful narrative choices, ensuring that each death resonates with the overarching story.

Even key figures such as Homelander and Butcher find themselves under existential threats. A lack of resolution for Homelander would frustrate audiences given his role as the primary antagonist, while Butcher’s character arc, fraught with moral ambiguity, suggests he too is due for a significant conclusion.

Whatever Happens, Ryan Absolutely Must Survive The Boys Season 5

Ryan Has Come to Symbolize The Boys’ Happy Ending

Among the cast, the character that must be shielded from the writers’ brutality is Ryan Butcher. He embodies a bridge between the worlds of supes and non-supes, with the shadow of Homelander cast over him and his mother Becca Butcher guiding his moral compass. Ryan’s narrative arc throughout The Boys has represented a clash of ideals—caught between the corrupting influence of his father and the foundational morals instilled in him by his mother.

Ultimately, Ryan signifies hope for the future of The Boys. Given his potential to surpass Homelander in power, Ryan represents the notion that true strength can come from empathy and moral righteousness, rather than tyranny and chaos. His character symbolizes the possibility of a harmonious existence between supes and humans, challenging the current status quo spearheaded by both Homelander and Butcher.

As the events of Season 4 left Ryan teetering toward darkness—exacerbated by the accidental killing of Mallory—his journey remains crucial. If he were to perish, it would extinguish the flicker of hope within the narrative, leading to a grim conclusion in which either Homelander or Butcher prevails on their catastrophic path. Instead, a resolution that allows Ryan to thrive could lend a sense of fulfillment, redeeming the struggles endured over five seasons.

Why It’s Okay If Hughie Dies in The Boys Season 5

Hughie Is More Expendable Than Ryan for The Boys

Jack Quaid as Hughie covered in blood in The Boys.

Conversely, some may argue that Hughie Campbell, portrayed by Jack Quaid, could be seen as a more expendable character for the narrative’s resolution. Serving as a relatable anchor for viewers, Hughie advocates for moderation amidst the chaos, often representing the voice of reason. His survival in Garth Ennis’s original comic conclusion adds a layer of hope to an otherwise bleak outcome.

However, the introduction of Ryan has shifted that dynamic significantly. While Hughie echoes hope, it is ultimately Ryan—with his dual heritage and stronger ties to both realms—who embodies the potential for unity. Hughie’s narrative arc could culminate in noble sacrifice, perhaps saving Starlight or standing against Butcher’s violent agenda. Such a twist might even catalyze a transformation in Butcher, reminiscent of the connections drawn in the past to Butcher’s deceased brother, Lenny.

While there are numerous ways to craft Hughie’s demise without steeping the narrative in hopelessness, Ryan’s survival is paramount. His death would signify a loss of potential, rendering the conclusion not just tragic but utterly devoid of optimism.

Source & Images