The Ideal Version of Steve Rogers for Chris Evans in Avengers: Doomsday That Fans Won’t Expect

There’s growing excitement surrounding Chris Evans’s return to the Marvel Cinematic Universe (MCU) in the upcoming Avengers: Doomsday. Although initial reports confirm his participation, the specifics of his role remain shrouded in mystery. Could he reprise his beloved portrayal of Steve Rogers, or might we see him in a completely different capacity? With this uncertainty, I propose an intriguing option from the comics that could not only be thrilling but also respectful of Evan’s iconic character trajectory.

According to The Wrap, Chris Evans is set to join the cast of Avengers: Doomsday in an undisclosed role. Given this ambiguity, it’s possible that Evans could portray a variant of Steve Rogers, similar to his appearance as Johnny Storm in the upcoming Deadpool & Wolverine film. However, I believe I’ve identified the perfect character for him—one that showcases a different facet of his acting prowess without undermining Captain America’s satisfying arc concluded in Avengers: Endgame.

The Conclusion of Steve Rogers’s Story in Avengers: Endgame

Captain America’s Final Moments and His Legacy

At the end of Avengers: Endgame, viewers witness Steve Rogers returning the Infinity Stones to their original timelines. Rather than resuming his place in the present-day MCU, Steve chooses to embrace a different path—staying in the 1940s to finally be with Peggy Carter and fulfill the promise of a long-awaited dance.

This poignant decision emphasizes that Steve Rogers deserved a happy ending after a lifetime of sacrifice. Following this conclusion, the elderly Steve passes his shield to Sam Wilson, symbolizing a seamless transition into the next chapter for Captain America. This leads to the notion that resurrecting the original Rogers in Avengers: Doomsday could risk diminishing the impact of this perfect send-off.

The Excitement of Chris Evans as a Villain in Avengers: Doomsday

Embracing the Dark Side of the MCU

Instead of reprising Captain America, I am more intrigued to see Chris Evans step into a villainous role. Portraying a character opposite to the honorable ethos of Captain America would be refreshing and engaging. Evans has successfully shown his capacity for portraying charming yet sinister characters, as exemplified through his performances in Knives Out and The Gray Man, both of which highlight his versatility as an actor.

With Robert Downey Jr. also set to play Doctor Doom in Avengers: Doomsday, there appears to be an interest in resurrecting past heroes as antagonists, setting the stage for a thrilling narrative. This opens up the possibility of other former MCU actors returning in villainous roles, elevating the stakes for the new team of heroes.

My Theory: Chris Evans as Hydra’s Captain America

Exploring Secret Empire’s Hydra Supreme

With the notion of Evans as a villain, I would be thrilled to see him bring to life the character of Hydra Supreme from the Secret Empire storyline. In this 2017 comic event, Steve Rogers is ensnared as a sleeper agent for Hydra—a development that stems from the Red Skull manipulating reality. Rogers becomes Hydra Supreme, leading a massive coup against the government.

This darker interpretation of Captain America has captivated audiences, despite its brevity in the comics. The shocking reveal of Rogers’s allegiance when he declares “Hail Hydra”created sensational discourse, adding depth to his character. Indeed, a portrayal of Hydra’s Captain America would showcase a radically different side of Chris Evans.

Endgame’s Subtle Reference to Hydra’s Captain America

A Hidden Easter Egg in the Time Heist

Chris Evans’s return could serve as a fulfilling exploration of the Hydra Captain America concept first hinted at in Avengers: Endgame. Imagine a narrative where a darker version of Rogers emerges from an alternate reality where the Red Skull employs the Mind Stone to corrupt him during World War II. Such an arc not only enriches the story but also crafts an intriguing twist for the audience.

Avengers: Doomsday is poised for its release in May 2026, and anticipation is building for how these character dynamics will unfold.

Source & Images