The Identity of the One Man Wyatt Earp Killed Before the Tombstone Incident

Kurt Russell’s portrayal of Wyatt Earp in the 1993 film Tombstone paints the legendary lawman as a quick-triggered gunslinger. However, historical records reveal that the real Wyatt Earp was involved in only one confirmed killing before the infamous Gunfight at the O.K. Corral, which serves as the centerpiece of the movie. Earp, a respected law enforcement officer in the Old West, was known for his skills with the six-shooter revolver, a common weapon of the era. Despite the evolving narrative surrounding his character over the years, he remains largely viewed as a heroic figure within the annals of American history.

Nevertheless, Earp’s legacy is not without its shadows. Modern historians have debated his reputation, labeling him a coward, gambler, and even a murderer. While primary-source evidence from the 19th century is scarce, various accounts have emerged that provide insight into Earp’s actions. A critical incident involved George Hoyt, the only individual Earp killed before the events depicted in Tombstone.

The Incident with George Hoyt

Earp’s First Kill: A Drunken Cowboy

The event in question took place in July 1878, when a 30-year-old Wyatt Earp was serving as an Assistant Marshal in Dodge City, Kansas. A group of intoxicated cowboys, including George Hoyt, discharged their firearms in a local theater. Fortunately, no one was harmed, but the incident scared the comedian performing on stage, prompting him to escape the area. The news of the disturbance spread quickly through the town. In response to the chaos, Earp and Officer Bat Masterson, alongside a mob of enraged citizens, rode out to confront the cowboys, who quickly fled the scene.

Tombstone Key Details
Release Date	Budget	Box Office	RT Tomatometer Score	RT Popcornmeter Score
December 25th, 1993	$25 million	$73.2 million	74%	93%

During the chase, Earp and his posse began shooting at the fleeing cowboys, with a bullet striking Hoyt, causing him to fall from his horse. Although Earp claimed to have shot Hoyt dead, historical records indicate a different truth. The Dodge City Times later reported that Hoyt succumbed to gangrene resulting from his wound, passing away 26 days later after enduring a torturous death.

Earp’s Shooting Incidents: More Than Meets the Eye

Earp’s Law Enforcement in the Context of Firearms

Throughout his law enforcement career, Wyatt Earp exhibited a willingness to utilize his firearm. While he was involved in numerous shooting incidents, the actual number of fatalities attributed to him is surprisingly low. Reports suggest that Earp is associated with the deaths of only about five men during his extensive years on the frontier, which includes those killed during the Gunfight at the O.K. Corral.

Initially, Earp carried a Colt Single Action Army Revolver, later transitioning to the Colt Buntline Special—a unique revolver crafted for the writer and journalist Ned Buntline. One major contributing factor to the low fatality count associated with Earp may be the limited lethality of firearms in that period. Old West revolvers were far less accurate and powerful than modern-day firearms; this means that even at close range, a shot might not strike vital organs capable of delivering instant death. Additionally, the quality of cartridges available at the time likely diminished the effectiveness of the guns. Hence, while Earp’s character in Tombstone embodies lethal prowess, historical evidence suggests his actual body count was far lower than cinematic portrayals might imply.

For further reading, visit The Gaslamp Foundation.

Source & Images