The Original Reveal of Doctor Who’s Valeyard Was Far Superior

The Valeyard stands out as one of the more perplexing figures in the expansive universe of Doctor Who. An unused narrative originally crafted for the Third Doctor could have significantly clarified this enigmatic character. With a legacy spanning over six decades, it is inevitable that Doctor Who‘s continuity may occasionally become convoluted. Compounding this complexity is the presence of a time-traveling alien protagonist capable of regenerating, effectively manipulating all of time and space.

Throughout the show’s long history, various incarnations of the Doctor have emerged, yet only a select few have become recognized as canonical representations. The classic series introduced several intriguing variants with ambiguous ties to the Doctor, leading to a lack of clarity surrounding their origins. Among these characters, The Valeyard has proven particularly challenging to integrate within the show’s logic, depicted as a future version of the Doctor who has exhausted his regenerations. However, an undiscovered story could have provided essential insights into The Valeyard’s true nature.

The Master as Doctor Who’s Valeyard: A More Coherent Narrative

Flaws in Doctor Who’s Logic Regarding The Valeyard

In a previously unproduced Doctor Who storyline intended for the Third Doctor, a darker interpretation of The Master was proposed, potentially positioning him as a sinister counterpart to the Doctor. Historically, the Master has always been one of the Doctor’s fiercest adversaries. Yet, intertwining his narrative with that of The Valeyard could have offered a fascinating blend of chaos and complexity within the show’s broader storyline, especially given The Valeyard’s role in a Sixth Doctor narrative.

Unfortunately, the true nature of The Valeyard remains ambiguous within the show’s framework, leading to apparent contradictions, particularly as the series has evolved beyond the Twelfth regeneration of the Doctor. By integrating The Master as a figurative embodiment of The Valeyard, who continually returns to challenge the Doctor, the character could have significantly enriched the show’s narrative landscape, making him a more meaningful addition to the Doctor Who lore.

The Unsolved Mystery of The Valeyard

The Doctor and The Valeyard in The Trial of the Time Lord

The Valeyard was initially slated to appear during the intriguing transitional period between the Sixth and Twelfth Doctors; however, he never materialized in the storyline. Since then, the Doctor has undergone significant transformations, including a new regeneration cycle and revelations as The Timeless Child, adding layers of complexity previously unknown to them.

Adding to the ongoing dilemma is the emergence of a bi-generational incident in which the Fourteenth Doctor effectively split into two distinct entities, manifesting as the Fifteenth Doctor. Under the current understanding, the remaining Fourteenth Doctor has presumably exhausted their regeneration potential. This instigates a question: unless David Tennant’s Fourteenth Doctor rejects his retirement, takes on the mantle of The Valeyard, and pursues the Doctor to absorb their regenerations for survival, the enigma of The Valeyard continues to linger, marking him as a notable unresolved mystery within the rich lore of Doctor Who.

Source & Images