Top 10 Changes for Edward Cullen’s Character in Twilight TV Remake

As the highly anticipated TV remake of Twilight gears up for production, it’s the perfect opportunity to reflect on Edward Cullen’s complex legacy and examine how the upcoming show can enhance the portrayal of its iconic protagonist. Edward Cullen is a character that divides opinion almost as much as the franchise itself. To some fans, he embodies the quintessential brooding romantic hero—a Byronic vampire with a hidden heart of gold. To others, he epitomizes a controlling, possessive figure whose brand of vampirism is often viewed as problematic.

The TV adaptation is set to draw from Midnight Sun, Stephenie Meyer’s retelling of her original novel that narrates the story from Edward’s perspective. While the plot remains largely the same, emphasizing Edward’s viewpoint provides deeper insights into his character. This shift may help address several concerns that fans and critics alike have raised in recent years, such as his troubling behavior characterized by stalking and a stark lack of humor.

1. Edward Should Be Less Obsessive and Possessive

Edward’s Infamous Quality Hasn’t Aged Well

The most glaring flaw in Edward’s characterization has been his possessive behavior towards Bella. This pervasive trait plays out repeatedly throughout the series. Even though the film adaptations toned this down, the crux of the issue remains. Edward’s actions—such as limiting Bella’s interactions with Jacob in Eclipse or even orchestrating her kidnapping—underscore the problematic nature of his obsession.

What complicates this situation is how these behaviors are often romanticized within the series. Given that Edward is a vampire and Bella a human, his actions are sometimes framed as protective instincts. While this merits consideration in certain scenarios, it doesn’t absolve him of the responsibility he bears for withholding crucial information and thereby disempowering Bella.

2. Edward Needs to Experience More Growth and Change

A Longer Runtime Offers Chances for Introspection

To foster a more compelling narrative, the TV remake must ensure that Edward evolves meaningfully over time. With a longer runtime, the series can devote more attention to his character development—something the film adaptations often neglected in favor of Bella’s arc. As a result, Edward often came off as static. However, the fresh perspective of Midnight Sun calls for an exploration of his complexities, helping audiences better relate to him.

3. Edward Should Exhibit Greater Maturity

Edward’s Advanced Age Makes His Immaturity Stand Out

Despite being an immortal vampire, Edward often displays a level of immaturity that feels out of place for his age. His occasional pettiness and brooding demeanor can come off as unintentionally humorous, undermining the serious tone of his character. Therefore, the TV remake should strive to portray Edward as more mature, which would anchor his character and render him more relatable to modern audiences who may seek depth in their protagonists.

4. Twilight’s Remake Needs to Reinvent Edward as a Classic Vampire

The Cullen Family’s Bloodless Vampirism Lacks Authenticity

In the original stories, the Cullens are depicted as “vegetarian” vampires, feeding on animal blood instead of humans. This quirky portrayal strips the mythology of its inherent darkness, rendering Edward less threatening. The upcoming adaptation would benefit from allowing Edward to embrace a more traditional vampire persona, which would invite more complexity and moral ambiguity into the storyline.

5. The TV Remake Should Delve Deeper into Edward’s Backstory

Edward’s Tragic Origins Make Him More Relatable

To enrich the narrative, the adaptation of Midnight Sun should emphasize Edward’s backstory. Born in 1901, he endured the loss of his parents during the 1918 influenza outbreak—an event that led to his transformation into a vampire. This profound tragedy not only encapsulates his character but also shapes his motivations. Addressing these elements in the remake could foster a deeper connection between Edward and the viewers.

6. Edward Needs a Sense of Humor

Edward’s Original Character Was Overly Somber

One of the most significant improvements that the adaptation could implement is developing Edward’s sense of humor. Often portrayed as overly serious, Edward’s character would benefit from moments of levity and charm, making him a more engaging protagonist. An infusion of humor would not only redefine him in the eyes of the audience but would also contribute to a more dynamic on-screen presence.

7. Edward Must Be Honest with Bella

Clear Communication Could Avert Major Conflicts

While Bella’s character could see some changes, Edward’s communication failures are crucial to many of the saga’s conflicts. For example, the entire premise of New Moon stems from Edward’s unwillingness to communicate with Bella. The television remake should emphasize the importance of open dialogue between them, allowing for a deeper emotional connection and averting misunderstandings that have driven the plot in previous adaptations.

8. Edward Should Resolve His Rivalry with Jacob

The Edward and Jacob Rivalry Became a Memorable Meme

The infamous rivalry between Edward and Jacob was a defining aspect of the series. However, the remake could subvert audience expectations by presenting a more friendly dynamic. If Edward were to embrace Jacob as a friend rather than a rival, it would create a more unpredictable narrative while also showcasing Edward’s growth, making him a more appealing character overall.

9. Edward Needs to Respect Bella’s Agency

Edward Often Ignored Bella’s Personal Boundaries

Throughout the series, Edward’s actions often disregarded Bella’s autonomy under the guise of protection. The remake should portray a more nuanced character who respects Bella’s independence. By prioritizing her feelings and choices, Edward can transform into a more supportive partner, giving viewers a healthier representation of relationships.

10. Edward Should Not Sparkle

Dropping the Sparkling Vampire Lore Is Essential

Finally, to keep the remake grounded, the infamous element of sparkling vampires must be eliminated. While this aspect was at odds with traditional vampire lore even during the original series, maintaining the core elements of the vampire myth will enhance believability and offer viewers an authentic experience.

In conclusion, the upcoming Twilight saga is a chance to reshape Edward Cullen into a far more relatable and engaging character. By addressing these changes, the series can resonate with both old fans and newcomers alike. Twilight remains available for streaming on Hulu for those wanting to revisit the story before its refreshed adaptation.

Source & Images