Please be advised that this article discusses themes including murder, sexual assault, and other distressing crimes.
Years post its original conclusion, Criminal Minds continues to dominate the crime procedural landscape. Often touted as the quintessential police drama of its era, the series has left an indelible mark on audiences, prompting viewers to search for similar offerings. While Criminal Minds: Evolution has already premiered its third season, the legacy of the original series persists as the benchmark for future narratives. Its memorable characters and chilling plotlines encapsulated a unique essence that remains challenging to replicate.
Throughout its 15-season run, the show’s most notorious aspect was undoubtedly its portrayal of the “unsub” (short for “Unknown Subject”). The opening of each episode typically showcased the unsub’s distinct modus operandi—often revealing their latest victim—thereby initiating a gripping and suspenseful narrative. With over 300 episodes and just as many unsubs, certain characters resonate more than others, due to particularly bizarre kill methods or the notable actors who portrayed them. For some, it’s simply the unsettling nature of their crimes that makes them stand out.
10
Stanley Howard
“Scared to Death”(Season 3, Episode 3)
Stanley Howard, played by Michael O’Keefe, is a psychiatrist who manipulated his patients’ phobias to inflict harm. From confining a claustrophobic woman to a box to allowing an aquaphobic man to drown, Howard relished the fear he instigated. The revelation that he is a family man, with a child terrified of the dark, heightens the terror—hinting at the potential danger he posed to those close to him if he remained free.
Each episode of Criminal Minds typically uses poignant quotes to frame the narrative, with the opening and closing quotes resonating powerfully. Season 3, Episode 3 begins with wise words from Lao Tzu and culminates with an inspiring quote from Eleanor Roosevelt, encapsulating the theme of overcoming fear—an ironic juxtaposition against Howard’s malicious deeds.
9
Benjamin Cyrus
“Minimal Loss”(Season 4, Episode 3)
In “Minimal Loss,”the episode draws inspiration from actual events, notably the notorious 1993 Waco siege. The narrative finds agents Spencer Reid (Matthew Gray Gubler) and Emily Prentiss (Paget Brewster) thrust into a dire hostage crisis at a religious cult. Notably, the character Benjamin Cyrus (portrayed by Luke Perry) stands out as a charismatic yet deeply sinister cult leader and predatory figure, differentiating himself from typical serial killers by being a serial abuser who exploited his religious authority.
8
Tobias Hankel
“The Big Game”(Season 2, Episode 14)
Tobias Hankel, played by James Van Der Beek, tormented the BAU across two episodes, haunted by a traumatic upbringing. Initially, the confusion surrounding multiple killer suspects unfolded, only for the truth to reveal Tobias as the singular perpetrator during a harrowing abduction and torture of Reid. The repercussions of his actions echoed throughout the series, leaving permanent scars on both Reid and Jennifer “JJ” Jareau (A.J. Cook).
7
John Curtis AKA The Replicator
“The Silencer”(Season 8, Episode 1)
Mark Hamill’s portrayal of John Curtis, an FBI insider turned killer, created one of the series’ most chilling villains. Targeting the BAU, Curtis modeled his brutal acts after notorious historical killers. His dual role within law enforcement while executing heinous crimes heightened the discomfort viewers felt, as he continuously taunted the team, using his intelligence for malevolence.
6
Adam Rain
“The Lesson”(Season 8, Episode 10)
Renowned horror actor Brad Dourif delivers a haunting performance as Adam Rain, who awakens from a coma with significant brain damage and a distorted perception of reality, recalling the trauma of his father’s murder. His poignant use of his victims as puppets in reenactments of violence is a harrowing depiction, clearly showcasing the depths of his madness.
5
Evening Morrison
“All That Remains”(Season 8, Episode 14)
In a chilling portrayal, Sophi Bairley plays teenage killer Sera Morrison, whose envy propels her to murder her mother and sister. Despite her academic prowess and potential for success, Sera exhibits a chilling detachment, successfully redirecting suspicion away from herself while displaying a profound lack of remorse.
4
George Foyet AKA The Reaper
“Omnivore”(Season 4, Episode 18)
With chilling effectiveness, C. Thomas Howell’s George Foyet, also known as The Reaper, represents one of the most notorious antagonists in the series. Echoing the infamy of the Zodiac Killer, Foyet’s thrill in tormenting his victims before death solidified his terror-inducing legacy in the show—including his direct ties to unit chief Aaron “Hotch” Hotchner’s tragic family saga.
3
Anita & Roger Roycewood
“Mosley Lane”(Season 5, Episode 16)
The infamy of spouse killers Anita (Beth Grant) and Roger Roycewood (Bud Cort) perfectly captures the horror of their macabre partnership. Each year, this unholy couple abducted a child, only to execute them once they grew too old or challenging to control. The gruesome details of Anita drugging children and cremating them alive render their crimes amongst the most horrific in Criminal Minds history.
2
Billy Flynn
“Our Darkest Hour”(Season 5, Episode 23)
Tim Curry’s portrayal of Billy Flynn in Criminal Minds drew parallels with his iconic role as Pennywise. As the Prince of Darkness, Flynn emerges as a terrifying figure—a real-life serial rapist and murderer with an estimated 200 victims. His haunting tactic of leaving witnesses adds a layer of psychological horror to his already grotesque legacy.
1
Peter Lewis AKA Mr. Scratch
“Mr. Scratch”(Season 10, Episode 21)
Despite being a relatively late addition to the series, Bodhi Elfman’s Peter Lewis—also known as Mr. Scratch—stands out for his insidious method of manipulation. Rather than directly committing murder, Lewis exploits his intellectual prowess to orchestrate his plans through hypnotism, compelling others to kill. His unnerving ability to turn accomplices into instruments of violence solidifies his status as one of the most disturbing characters in the show’s long history.
Related Articles:
Criminal Minds Original Star Reacts to Matthew Gray Gubler’s Return as Reid in Evolution Season 3
16:43
Criminal Minds: Evolution Season 4 Teased by Star with Positive Update as Season 3’s Filming Concludes
13:23
Criminal Minds: The Transformation of Aubrey Plaza’s Cat Adams into a Notorious Killer
12:04
Leave a Reply