Top 10 Hidden Gem Horror Films of the 2010s

The 2010s emerged as a remarkable decade for the horror genre, showcasing an impressive array of films that have reshaped the landscape of fear in cinema. With standout titles such as The Witch, Get Out, and A Quiet Place leading the charge, this era also saw the rise of talented directors like Jordan Peele and Robert Eggers, who introduced new perspectives to horror storytelling on a global stage.

In addition to these prominent films, the decade was home to numerous underappreciated gems that, while lacking the mainstream spotlight, offered captivating narratives and distinctive characters. Exploring the best obscure horror movies from the 2010s, we uncover a treasure trove of unique stories—ranging from folklore-infused terrors to chilling gore fests—that linger in the minds of viewers long after the credits roll.

10 Would You Rather (2012)

Directed By David Guy Levy

Taking a sinister spin on the classic party game, Would You Rather is not for the faint-hearted. This darkly inventive film by David Guy Levy portrays a harrowing night filled with disturbing choices where players must opt for horrific acts—like being stabbed or inflicting injury upon themselves—in pursuit of a life-changing prize.

With a shocking twist that leaves audiences reeling, the film captivates with its intense premise and visceral violence, heightened by stellar performances from the cast. Although it’s not the easiest watch, those who endure until the conclusion are rewarded with a heart-stopping cinematic experience.

9 Beyond The Black Rainbow (2010)

Directed By Panos Cosmatos

In his feature debut, director Panos Cosmatos delivers a mind-bending experience with Beyond the Black Rainbow, a striking blend of sci-fi and horror. The film follows a psychedelic narrative centered on a young woman with telekinetic abilities attempting to escape a dystopian commune, often challenging viewers to unravel its central theme.

With its hallucinatory visuals and haunting soundtrack, this film stands out for its sheer bizarre artistry, making it a must-watch for fans of unconventional horror. Cosmatos’ unique style ensures that few can rival the chaotic weirdness presented in this unforgettable viewing experience.

8 Apostle (2018)

Directed By Gareth Edwards

Drawing inspiration from the classic The Wicker Man, Apostle follows a young man’s desperate quest to rescue his sister from a sinister cult on a remote Welsh island. Transitioning from high-octane action films, Gareth Evans proves his directorial range with this atmospheric tale steeped in tension.

Watch the trailer

The film effectively balances gothic symbolism and strong performances—particularly from Dan Stevens and Michael Sheen—establishing a gripping narrative that resonates with audiences.

7 The Hallow (2015)

Directed By Corin Hardy

Recognized as one of the finest Irish horror films in recent years, The Hallow introduces viewers to conservationist Adam Hitchens, portrayed by Joseph Mawle, whose family faces terrifying supernatural forces in the Irish countryside. The film artfully combines practical effects with its captivating setting to create a genuinely frightening atmosphere.

Despite its low profile, The Hallow has received rave reviews, illustrating how effective horror can thrive outside of the mainstream spotlight and compelling audiences to crave a continuation of its haunting narrative.

6 The Ritual (2017)

Directed By David Bruckner

Based on the 2011 novel by Adam Nevill, The Ritual is an impressive example of supernatural folk horror. The film follows a group of friends hiking through a Scandinavian wilderness, unaware they are being stalked by the Jötunn, a fearsome figure from Norse mythology. Led by Rafe Spall, this atmospheric tale builds suspense over its 94-minute runtime.

With its stunning cinematography and psychological depth, The Ritual skillfully blends horror elements, offering a polished experience that remains unsettling throughout.

5 The Devil’s Candy (2017)

Directed By Sean Byrne

Featuring an impressive 93% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes, The Devil’s Candy showcases Australian filmmaker Sean Byrne’s talent for crafting suspenseful narratives. The film portrays a family gripped by fear as they confront a killer influenced by demonic forces.

Arriving with a powerful soundtrack and solid performances, this film is regarded as one of the 2010s’ hidden treasures, a must-see for horror aficionados.

4 Jug Face (2013)

Directed By Chad Crawford Kinkle

Embodying the spirit of low-budget horror, Jug Face presents an unconventional story of an off-grid community that worships a mysterious creature residing in a pit, demanding human sacrifices to retain their way of life. This eerie premise is propelled by captivating performances from Lauren Ashley Carter and Sean Bridgers.

The film resonates through its unique storytelling, highlighting how creativity can thrive on limited budgets to produce powerful horror narratives.

3 The Invitation (2015)

Directed By Karyn Kusama

In her chilling film The Invitation, Karyn Kusama delivers a gripping psychological thriller based around a dinner party that conceals sinister motives tied to a doomsday cult. Despite featuring prominent actors like Michael Huisman and John Carroll Lynch, the film remains largely overlooked.

Watch the trailer

With its edge-of-your-seat tension and stunning narrative twists, this film is a standout in the horror genre, deserving of recognition for its remarkable crafting and unforgettable climax.

2 13 Cameras (2016)

Directed By Victor Zarcoff

13 Cameras, a gritty low-budget horror effort by Victor Zarcoff, centers on Gerald, a voyeuristic landlord who uses hidden cameras to monitor his unsuspecting tenants. While it may not redefine the genre, it masterfully builds tension, thanks to a shocking twist and a chilling performance by the late Neville Archambault.

Movie	Rotten Tomatoes Rating
13 Cameras (2015)	77%
14 Cameras (2018)	22%
15 Cameras (2023)	67%

1 Hush (2016)

Directed By Mike Flanagan

Before gaining acclaim for series such as The Haunting of Hill House, Mike Flanagan created Hush, a highly regarded yet underrated horror thrill ride. Starring Kate Siegel, the film focuses on a deaf-mute writer thrust into a perilous struggle for survival against a deadly intruder.

With an impressive 91% approval rating on Rotten Tomatoes, Hush exemplifies expert suspense filmmaking, effectively utilizing claustrophobic tension and delivering potent performances that define it as one of the finest obscure horror films of recent years.

Source & Images