Top 10 Supernatural Episodes from the Eric Kripke Era

The Best Episodes of Eric Kripke’s Supernatural

Eric Kripke is best known as the creator and showrunner of the iconic fantasy series Supernatural. Originally conceptualized to wrap up after three seasons, Kripke extended the narrative to five due to overwhelming fan support. After his departure post-season 5, other prominent figures, including Sera Gamble and Jeremy Carver, took the reins, ultimately culminating in a remarkable 15-season run that concluded in 2020. Notably, Kripke returned as an executive consultant for season 7, influencing the show’s development even after his exit.

The initial five seasons, referred to as the “Kripke era,”are celebrated for their distinctive tone, rich lore, and emotional storytelling. This phase established the Winchesters’ backstory and set the stage for monumental plot points, including the looming Biblical Apocalypse. Within these five seasons, numerous episodes resonate deeply with audiences, showcasing strong narratives and significant character development. Here, we explore ten standout episodes from the Kripke era that left a lasting impact.

10 Nightshifter

Season 2, Episode 12

In the aftermath of season 1’s establishment of the series’ horror format, season 2 introduced the critically acclaimed episode “Nightshifter.” This episode showcased Sam and Dean grappling with the ramifications of navigating a hostile world without their father, portraying them as misunderstood fugitives rather than heroes. As they investigate a shapeshifter in a tense hostage scenario, the dynamic between the brothers and the civilians becomes a cornerstone of the plot.

“Nightshifter” captivates with its thrilling heist narrative, where the Winchesters must convince terrified civilians of their innocence while outsmarting law enforcement. The episode is praised for highlighting Sam and Dean’s cunning, particularly how they deceive both the FBI and SWAT teams during their escape.

9 Mystery Spot

Season 3, Episode 11

“Mystery Spot” stands out as one of the most inventive and comedic episodes of Supernatural. The episode features a time-looping narrative that constantly puts Dean in absurdly fatal situations, making for a unique blend of humor and drama. The iconic sequences within the mysterious location showcase how the show expertly navigates different genres while maintaining emotional stakes.

The tonal shifts within the episode—ranging from laugh-out-loud moments to heartbreaking despair—demonstrate the series’ versatility. As Sam desperately attempts to prevent Dean’s untimely deaths, viewers witness the psychological toll it takes on him when the time loop finally ends, leading him down a dark path in pursuit of vengeance against the Trickster.

8 Lazarus Rising

Season 4, Episode 1

The explosive premiere of season 4, “Lazarus Rising,” marks a pivotal moment in Supernatural lore. The episode opens with Dean clawing his way out of the grave, introducing the viewer to Castiel, a powerful angel, amid spectacular visuals. This episode sets the stage for the Apocalypse narrative, which Kripke intricately weaves throughout the show’s fabric.

Dean’s resurgence represents a significant moment by unintentionally breaking the first Seal in Hell, initiating a chain of cataclysmic events. As the series embarks on its overarching theme of good vs. evil, Dean’s resurrection heightens the stakes and propels the story towards an epic collision with divine forces.

7 In the Beginning

Season 4, Episode 3

“In the Beginning” takes viewers back to 1973, exploring the Winchester family’s past and the genesis of key characters. During a time-travel episode, Dean confronts younger versions of his parents, Mary and John, unveiling familial histories that impact the series’ timeline. This episode enriches the narrative context of subsequent seasons, answering long-standing questions about Mary’s haunting past.

The episode serves to cultivate empathy for Mary, shedding light on her struggles and interactions with the Yellow-Eyed Demon. This critical exploration redefines the character’s significance and creates compelling connections to the present narrative, hence solidifying its place among the defining episodes of the Kripke era.

6 On The Head of a Pin

Season 4, Episode 16

This emotionally charged episode showcases Castiel’s moral conflicts as he begins questioning his orders from Heaven. The tension rises as Dean confronts Azazel’s torturer, Alistair, revealing horrifying truths about the Apocalypse and the irrevocable choices that the Winchesters must face. “On The Head of a Pin” builds on Castiel’s character depth and his evolving relationship with the brothers.

Moreover, this episode foreshadows Castiel’s future alliance with the Winchester brothers, hinting at deeper issues within the celestial hierarchy. The emotional weight of Dean’s realization about his own role in the impending Apocalypse contributes to the stakes, making it a pivotal installment in the series.

5 The Rapture

Season 4, Episode 20

Delving into the personal anguish of characters, “The Rapture” explores the devastating effects of angelic possession on humanity. The episode presents Castiel’s vessel, Jimmy Novak, whose harrowing experience as a host reflects the darker side of celestial beings. As Jimmy grapples with his freedom while contending with past traumas, this episode humanizes both him and the often cold nature of angels.

With Misha Collins delivers a powerful performance that distinguishes Jimmy from Castiel, the episode examines the collateral damage caused by divine intervention, making it a standout episode tinged with emotional resonance and moral quandaries.

4 The End

Season 5, Episode 4

The post-apocalyptic setting of “The End” creates a hauntingly reflective backdrop for exploring the themes of sacrifice and loss. Confronted with a dystopian future, Dean is forced to reckon with the dire consequences of the choices made in pursuit of defeating Lucifer and stopping the Apocalypse. The episode’s chilling portrayal of a world reshaped by demonic influence amplifies the stakes for the Winchesters.

As the narrative unfolds, viewers witness the bleak transformation of beloved characters, emphasizing the emotional toll of the ongoing battle between good and evil. The exploration of fate and choice makes “The End” an essential part of the overarching narrative.

3 Changing Channels

Season 5, Episode 8

In a humorous yet profound commentary on narrative structure, “Changing Channels” playfully melds various television genres, taking the Winchesters on a chaotic journey through comedic plots and engaging critiques of media culture. This episode is both entertaining and insightful, as Gabriel’s antics force Sam and Dean into roles reflecting their status as vessels.

TV Shows and Adverts in Supernatural’s “Changing Channels”
A sitcom
Dr. Sexy MD
A fictional Japanese gameshow, Nutcracker
A “Herpexia” advert for genital herpes
A CSI: Miami parody
A Knight Rider parody

The episode’s clever use of humor reveals deeper truths about the Winchesters’ predicaments and highlights Gabriel’s complex character, making “Changing Channels” an unforgettable entry in the series.

2 Abandon All Hope…

Season 5, Episode 10

The emotional weight of “Abandon All Hope…” is undeniable, as it features some of the most poignant deaths in Supernatural history. In a race against the clock to find Lucifer, Sam, Dean, and Castiel encounter fellow hunters, Bobby, Ellen, and Jo, culminating in a heart-wrenching final stand against insurmountable odds.

The episode expertly intertwines character deaths that resonate deeply with viewers, showcasing the fragility of life in the face of true evil. Ellen and Jo’s sacrifices highlight themes of love and loyalty, making their final moments profoundly impactful. This episode serves as a crucial turning point, unresolved plot threads weaving throughout the series and culminating in an unforgettable narrative experience.

1 Swan Song

Season 5, Episode 22

The season 5 finale, “Swan Song,” marks a majestic conclusion to Kripke’s era, painting an epic portrait of sacrifice and redemption. This episode intertwines the fates of Sam, Dean, and Lucifer in an electrifying climax that delivers emotional resolutions while setting the stage for future conflicts.

The revelation of Chuck as God and Sam’s ultimate confrontation with Lucifer culminates in a powerful emotional payoff, showcasing the series’ rich character development. Furthermore, the symbolic significance of the Impala echoes throughout the series, reflecting its status as an enduring emblem of the bond between the brothers. “Swan Song” not only ties up existing story arcs but foreshadows future narratives, solidifying its status as a landmark episode in the world of Supernatural.

Source & Images