Toy Story 5 Must Address The Franchise’s Missteps with the Lightyear Movie

Toy Story 5 is set to revive interest in Pixar’s Lightyear, which was deemed a miss for the studio upon its release in 2022. With its ambitious, meta approach to Buzz Lightyear’s origin story, Lightyear garnered little favorable response from audiences and critics alike. Many found the premise confusing, making it difficult for fans of the original Toy Story series to connect. As a result, it might seem logical for Pixar to downplay this less-successful installment. However, the upcoming Toy Story 5, scheduled for release in 2026, is likely to bring Lightyear back into focus.

Despite its connection to the critically acclaimed Toy Story franchise, Lightyear is not widely regarded among Pixar’s best offerings. While it wasn’t outright poor, its premise seemed unnecessary, complicating an already rich family-friendly narrative. The question remains: how can Pixar effectively acknowledge Lightyear in the context of Toy Story 5, given its mixed reception? This challenge presents both obstacles and opportunities for the studio.

Acknowledging Lightyear in Toy Story 5

The Connection Between Andy and Buzz

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BwPL0Md_QFQ

Lightyear | Teaser Trailer (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BwPL0Md_QFQ)

On a positive note, Lightyear provides crucial context for why Andy was so eager to own a Buzz Lightyear action figure in the original Toy Story film. The concept of Buzz as a product of the in-universe Lightyear film adds a layer of creativity to the storyline, even if it did not warrant an entire spinoff. As part of the narrative in Toy Story 5, the appearance of numerous commemorative Buzz toys as antagonists necessitates at least a nod to this connection. If Toy Story 5 celebrates the anniversary of Lightyear, it will inevitably intertwine the two storylines even further.

Potential for Toy Story 5 to Redeem Lightyear

The Disconnection Between Lightyear and Toy Story

Currently, Lightyear feels detached from the overall Toy Story narrative, despite its integral role in introducing Buzz. The upcoming Toy Story 5 presents a viable opportunity to bridge this gap. If the sequel addresses Lightyear, it could enhance the relevance of the spinoff, allowing it to become more integrated into the beloved franchise.

One approach might involve direct references to Lightyear, such as having characters celebrate its anniversary or even featuring a cameo by Chris Evans’ version of Buzz. While Toy Story 5 will certainly focus on Tim Allen’s Buzz, introducing elements from Lightyear could provide a fresh dynamic to the storyline.

Strategies for Integrating Lightyear Without Alienating Fans

Could Lightyear Be Retconned?

There remains the possibility that Toy Story 5 might choose to eliminate or retcon Lightyear from its canon altogether. If this route is taken, the film would need a plausible reason for Andy’s strong desire for the Buzz Lightyear toy. Fortunately, several avenues could be pursued.

For instance, popular toys can become highly sought after for reasons beyond movie fandom, as seen with other characters like Mr. Potato Head and Slinky Dog in the franchise. Perhaps Buzz’s allure can simply be attributed to its status as a groundbreaking toy. Alternatively, the success of the Buzz Lightyear video game featured in Toy Story 2 might provide a logical foundation for his popularity.

Toy Story Franchise Release Timeline
Movie	Year	Rotten Tomatoes Score
Toy Story	1995	100%
Toy Story 2	1999	100%
Toy Story 3	2010	98%
Toy Story 4	2019	97%
Lightyear	2022	74%
Toy Story 5	2026	TBC

Buzz Lightyear could simply be presented as an extraordinary toy, popular among children.
Alternatively, the success of the Buzz Lightyear video game could serve as the catalyst for the toy’s rise in popularity.

Ultimately, in light of these options, the creators of Toy Story 5 have the freedom to choose how, or whether, to integrate Lightyear into their narrative.

Source&Images