Toy Story’s Most Controversial Film Improves Significantly in 2024

Pixar’s Toy Story franchise stands as the studio’s most significant and beloved series. With a confirmed expansion into a fifth installment set for release in 2026, the franchise continues to thrive. As the film that launched Pixar into animation prominence, its legacy is well-established. The franchise encompasses four feature films, a spinoff, several animated shorts, and TV specials, cultivating a loyal fanbase eager to embrace new adventures in this unique universe.

Recent developments reveal intriguing plot insights for Toy Story 5, which will explore the conflict between beloved toys and advancing technology. The story will introduce a mechanical army of Buzz Lightyear toys, controlled by computers, posing new challenges for Woody and the crew. The announcement of this fifth installment was both a surprise and somewhat anticipated; while Toy Story 4 seemed to conclude Woody’s and Buzz’s saga definitively, the narrative arc had purportedly ended before in Toy Story 3. Nonetheless, this latest expansion allows Toy Story 4 to gain the recognition it deserves.

The Impact of Toy Story 5 on Toy Story 4’s Reception

The Controversial Reception of Toy Story 4

Woody and Bo Peep smiling at the end of Toy Story 4 — Pixar

Directed by Josh Cooley and released in 2019, Toy Story 4 arrived nine years after its predecessor. This installment revisits Woody, Buzz, and their toy companions as they adapt to their new owner, Bonnie. Woody finds himself feeling sidelined, as Bonnie shows a clear preference for other toys. His journey takes a transformative turn during a family road trip, where he reunites with Bo Peep (voiced by Annie Potts), gaining new insights into their existence and purpose, especially in the absence of Andy.

Despite achieving a remarkable 97% rating, Toy Story 4 faces criticism as it’s perceived as a contentious sequel, especially following the emotional closure offered by Toy Story 3. The movie became a commercial success, grossing over $1.074 billion, making it the top-grossing film in the franchise, yet still struggled with its reputation as an “unnecessary” addition.

Now that Toy Story 5 is officially happening, Toy Story 4 can be reevaluated in a more favorable light. No longer can it solely bear the weight of the franchise’s supposed failure to respect the conclusion of Toy Story 3. Instead, as the saga continues, Toy Story 4’s narrative may be appreciated for its contributions to the overall storyline.

Reevaluating Toy Story 4’s Legacy: The Challenge of Following Toy Story 3

The Flawless Conclusion of Toy Story 3

Although Toy Story 4 is undeniably well-executed, its legacy has been complicated by the lasting impact of Toy Story 3. Released 11 years after Toy Story 2, the third film posed crucial questions regarding the fate of Woody and his friends as the toys faced abandonment by their owner, Andy, who was preparing for college.

Toy Story 3’s climax offered heartfelt closure, leaving audiences with a sense of completion—one that many felt was undermined by the arrival of Toy Story 4. In its final moments, Woody acknowledges the changes in their lives, opting to donate the toys to Bonnie, a gesture that signified moving on. This ending was universally acclaimed and considered the definitive closure to the franchise’s narrative arc.

However, Toy Story 4’s entry prompted a wave of backlash, with many labeling it “unnecessary,” creating the perception that it “ruined” the groundbreaking conclusion of the third film. As Toy Story 5 paves the way for a burst of fresh content, Toy Story 4 now has the chance to be appreciated on its own merits.

The Enduring Legacy of Toy Story 4

A Bright Future for Toy Story 4

With the anticipated release of Toy Story 5, the future looks promising for Toy Story 4. The confirmed sequel shines a light on the fourth film, enabling it to shed its undeserved reputation. Regardless of how Toy Story 5 performs, its existence validates Toy Story 4, offering it a chance to stand alongside its predecessors.

If Toy Story 5 aligns with expectations, it will reinforce Toy Story 4’s role in revitalizing the franchise. Conversely, if Toy Story 5 falls short, it may enhance nostalgia for Toy Story 4, allowing viewers to reevaluate its contributions. Time, as they say, can be a great ally, and as the Toy Story franchise continues to unfold with exciting narratives, Toy Story 4 will increasingly be lauded for its unique qualities—far beyond simply measuring up to earlier entries.

Source & Images