The debate surrounding the use of generative AI in the gaming industry is intensifying, particularly with the unveiling of a new title called Catly. Debuted at the 2024 Game Awards, this AAA open-world MMO, developed by SuperAuthenti, is centered around various feline characters set in an engaging and colorful environment.
In its reveal trailer, Catly showcases lifelike cats interacting in a vibrant living space, alongside a customizable human character. Despite the visually appealing presentation, the game has faced backlash from the gaming community. Critics argue that the creation of its cat characters, cosmetics, and various game assets relies heavily on AI technology, leading some to dub it a scam.
Could Catly Be More Than Just an Adorable MMO?
According to information available on Catly’s Steam page, players can assume the roles of both cats and humans, embarking on adventures across stunning landscapes. The game’s description hints at a blend of cozy life simulation and MMO gameplay, promising players opportunities to foster bonds with their feline companions. An intriguing addition is the planned companion app for Apple Watch, allowing players to monitor their cats while on the move, thereby deepening the game’s immersive experience.
- Supported Platforms for Catly: PC, Switch, and Apple Watch
The controversy surrounding the use of generative AI in Catly extends beyond visuals. Critics have pointed out that some segments of the game’s Steam description appear to be poorly constructed, leading to speculation about the project’s authenticity. This has fueled fears that the game may not launch as promised, with additional doubts cast on its performance capability for platforms such as the Switch and Apple Watch if it indeed features hyperrealistic graphics.
this sentence already can tell it’s written by AI 😅 pic.twitter.com/IocEJAX24m — Nicкs (@NickolasSHP) December 13, 2024
Currently, an official release date for Catly remains unannounced. However, the Apple Watch app’s website suggests a tentative launch on June 1, 2025, contingent upon potential adjustments over the coming months.
As discussions regarding Catly gain momentum, developer SuperAuthenti is coming under scrutiny. User NotPeashyBee on Twitter highlighted connections between the studio and Kevin Yeung, noted for his involvement in blockchain and NFT gaming. Many gamers are concerned about the feasibility of a new studio producing a AAA MMO and securing endorsements from well-known influencers like Ninja at this stage.
The current discourse surrounding generative AI and blockchain technology has sparked significant ethical debates across various sectors, including gaming. Many in the industry express concerns over the environmental implications and the job losses these technologies may catalyze.
As of now, SuperAuthenti has yet to publicly address the allegations of AI-generated content in Catly and the related claims of being a blockchain scam. With controversy overshadowing the initial excitement for the game, it remains uncertain how Catly will be received upon its eventual release. There’s a possibility for a positive turnaround, especially if players are treated to a demo that showcases the game’s customization capabilities, akin to the approach taken by InZOI.
InZoi also faced backlash for incorporating AI in its customization options, particularly concerning item creation via prompts, illustrating the ongoing scrutiny in the gaming industry regarding AI use.
Leave a Reply