Understanding the Significance of ‘Agatha All Along’ Torah Reading and Its Impact on Jewish Fans

Fans, especially within the Jewish community, are excited about the MCU’s portrayal of William Kaplan, who is accurately depicted as Jewish. This representation stays true to the comics, where Billy Kaplan’s heritage is a key aspect. Episode 6 of *Agatha All Along*, titled “Familiar by Thy Side,” begins with his bar mitzvah, and the Torah reading by Billy may hold significant implications.

In previous instances, audiences have voiced concerns that Marvel has often strayed from honoring the rich diversity found in their comic storylines within films and television series. In *Agatha All Along*, some commentators noted that while Patti LuPone delivers a standout performance, the role of Lilia Calderu would have been more appropriate for a Romani actor, given Lilia’s identity as the Witch Queen of the Romani in the comics. Similar discussions surrounding Elizabeth Olsen as Wanda Maximoff and Robert Downey Jr. as Victor von Doom have also arisen. Fortunately, the creators behind the character of William “Billy” Kaplan adhered faithfully to the narrative from the comics and retained his Jewish identity.

The theme became particularly clear in that episode’s opening, showcasing Billy Kaplan at his bar mitzvah. This rite of passage marks a critical moment for Jewish boys and girls as they turn 13, symbolizing their entry into adulthood and the assumption of personal responsibility. During the celebration, the individual reads a segment of the Torah, often in a melodic style that presents its own challenges.

Could There Be a Deeper Significance Behind William’s Torah Reading?

William Kaplan's Torah reading segment, Agatha All Along — (Disney+)

In the show, William’s Torah portion appears to derive from the book of Leviticus, narrating the Incident of Nadav and Avihu, who were the sons of Aaron.

^{And read 11:1 And} the sons of Aaron took Nadav and Abihua a man from under him and put fire in them and put incense on it and offered strange fire before Yahweh which he did not command them. ^{12: And} fire came out from before Jehovah and consumed them, and they died before Jehovah.

^{Lev 10:1} The sons of Aaron, Nadav and Avihu, took each, his fire-dish; they put fire in them; they placed upon it incense; they offered before YHWH strange fire that He had not commanded them. ^10:2 Fire came forth from before YHWH and consumed them; they died before YHWH.

Note: YHWH is a transliteration meaning God.

In this scripture, the brothers brought forth “strange fire”and were punished, leading to their demise before God. Could this serve as a metaphor for the twins and their powers within the MCU? Is it foreshadowing the fate awaiting Billy and Tommy just moments after this passage is recited? They possess “strange fire,”or abilities, and soon after displaying these powers, their lives reach a critical juncture (or so we believed). Or might this be hinting at events yet to unfold? Perhaps I’m overanalyzing, but it certainly invites speculation.

What’s clear is that incorporating a Torah segment which resonates with the narrative surrounding Billy and Tommy was a thoughtful touch. Overall, enthusiasts were delighted by the execution of the bar mitzvah scene.

“Well done, Marvel. You nailed it!”

Following the episode’s release on October 16, many fans took to social media platforms such as Reddit to express their enthusiasm for the scene’s portrayal. One user shared their appreciation for how well it was executed and commended Joe Locke for his performance during the moment.

Congrats, Marvel. You did it right. byu/canalboatjoe inAgathaAllAlong

Some observers attributed the success of this scene to the showrunner, Jac Schaeffer, who has Jewish roots on her father’s side. Discussions also arose regarding the choice of Locke, a non-Jewish actor, for the role, with some expressing that “there will always be individuals disappointed that a Jewish actor was not cast,”highlighting the diversity of opinions.

Comment byu/RadiantRow5595 from discussionin Agatha All Along

Others were simply impressed by Locke’s vocal abilities and his accurate pronunciation.

Comment byu/canalboatjoe from discussionin Agatha All Along

Whether this aspect of his identity will continue to play a role in his narrative as he transitions from William Kaplan to Billy Maximoff remains to be seen, depending on Marvel and Disney’s approach in future storytelling.

Source