Viggo’s Decision: Major Challenges for Lord of the Rings’ Gollum Movie If Original Aragorn Concept Fails

Aragorn remains a pivotal figure in The Lord of the Rings saga, and his significance may be amplified in the upcoming film, The Lord of the Rings: The Hunt for Gollum. This upcoming decade is poised to be an exciting one for the franchise, with The Lord of the Rings: The War of the Rohirrim set to release in December 2024 and The Hunt for Gollum (tentative title) scheduled for 2026. However, the success of The Hunt for Gollum may hinge on an essential element concerning Aragorn, as screenwriter Philippa Boyens highlighted during a recent interview.

In a discussion with The Playlist, Boyens revealed that while the script for the film is still a work in progress, Aragorn is expected to play a crucial role. This is logical given that the storyline is anticipated to unfold in the timeframe between Bilbo’s birthday celebration and the Fellowship’s arrival at Moria, capturing Gollum’s perspective. Throughout this period, both Gandalf and Aragorn actively pursue Gollum, with Aragorn eventually capturing him, making the participation of Viggo Mortensen essential to the film’s narrative.

Will Aragorn Appear in The Hunt for Gollum?

The Importance of Aragorn in The Hunt for Gollum

Boyens expressed confidence that Aragorn will indeed be a part of The Hunt for Gollum, irrespective of Viggo Mortensen’s participation. She noted that discussions have already taken place with Mortensen, along with other notable figures like Andy Serkis and Peter Jackson, who will be directing and producing the film. Despite these discussions, Mortensen has yet to confirm his involvement, which poses a significant challenge for the project. Boyens summed up the sentiment of many fans by stating, “I cannot imagine anyone else playing Aragorn.”

Event	Year	Month	Date
Bilbo’s birthday party	3001	September	22
Gandalf began seeking news of Gollum and enlisted Aragorn’s help	3001	Unknown	Unknown
Gandalf and Aragorn renewed their search for Gollum	3009 – 3017	Unknown	Unknown
Sauron captured and tortured Gollum	3009 – 3017	Unknown	Unknown
Sauron released Gollum	3017	Unknown	Unknown
Aragorn captured Gollum	3017	Unknown	Unknown
Gollum escaped	3018	June	20
Gollum’s whereabouts lost, believed to have entered Moria	3018	August	Unknown
Frodo departs Bag End	3018	September	23
Council of Elrond convenes for the Fellowship’s formation	3018	October	25
Fellowship departs Rivendell	3018	December	25
Fellowship arrives at the West-gate of Moria	3019	January	13

Viggo Mortensen has been the embodiment of the heroic Aragorn throughout Warner Bros.’ The Lord of the Rings trilogy. However, the challenge of securing his participation in the new film cannot be overstated. With the core narrative involving Gandalf and Aragorn’s pursuit of Gollum, it is difficult to envision a successful adaptation without Mortensen’s iconic portrayal. Boyens implied that Mortensen would consider the script before making a decision, highlighting the importance of a compelling story to entice him back into the role.

The Challenges Ahead for The Lord of the Rings’ 2026 Movie

Potential Difficulties for The Lord of the Rings’ 2026 Film

Viggo Mortensen as Aragorn in Lord of the Rings.

Philippa Boyens’ remarks underscore the significant pressure on The Hunt for Gollum to bring Mortensen on board as Aragorn. His presence is deemed essential for the film’s narrative coherence as well as its commercial viability to LotR fans. Should this plan falter, the filmmakers would have to resort to a contingency strategy, significantly complicating the project. Losing Mortensen implies losing a magnet for the audience, which could unjustly tarnish the film’s box office potential, undermining the franchise’s bright prospects.

In the event Mortensen declines the role, a recasting or a script revision to diminish Aragorn’s role may ensue. This change could force a divergence from J.R.R. Tolkien’s originally established narrative, particularly outlined in the appendices. Notably, Ian McKellen is expected to reprise his role as Gandalf, which may necessitate him absorbing certain plot elements traditionally associated with Aragorn. While there’s the potential of employing AI technology to digitally integrate Mortensen’s likeness for cameo moments, a potential recast appears more plausible if Mortensen opts out.

Is Recasting Aragorn a Viable Option for the New Film?

The Risks of Recasting Aragorn in The Hunt for Gollum

Philippa Boyens hinted that recasting of Aragorn could be a possibility if Mortensen chooses not to return. It remains uncertain how effective this could be. Boyens suggested, “I suspect if he decides he doesn’t want to do it, we would still want him to be heavily involved,”indicating the possibility that Mortensen could have a hand in selecting a new actor for Aragorn, should it come to that. Alternatively, he might contribute to other creative solutions regarding his absence.

Recasting could present an odd juxtaposition, as Gandalf, Frodo, and Gollum are likely to retain their original portrayals. This mismatched continuity could detract from the overall coherence of the film.

Indeed, there’s a sentiment that recasting Aragorn poses a considerable challenge for The Lord of the Rings: The Hunt for Gollum. The legacy of Mortensen’s portrayal looms large. Alongside McKellen’s commitment, Elijah Wood acknowledged his enthusiasm for revisiting his role. In an interview with JoBlo, he expressed, “jumping back into a world that’s so beloved and means so much to me… would be awesome.”The inclusion of original cast members brings expectations, compelling the studio to find an actor who can convincingly share the screen with McKellen and other reprised characters.

As anticipation builds for The Lord of the Rings: The Hunt for Gollum, slated for release in 2026, the challenges of retaining the essence of the beloved characters while navigating potential casting dilemmas continue to loom large. Fans are keenly awaiting any news on Mortensen’s involvement and what adjustments might be made if he does not return.

For more on this topic, check sources such as The Playlist, JoBlo, and Variety.

Source & Images