Why Arnold Schwarzenegger’s Absence in Predator 2 Helped Save the Franchise Despite the Film’s Flaws

Arnold Schwarzenegger famously portrayed Dutch Schaefer, the modern warrior in the classic 1987 film Predator. Although fans might expect his return in the sequel Predator 2, the decision not to include him ultimately paved the way for the franchise’s enduring success. The Predator series is known for introducing a formidable cinematic monster from sci-fi and horror lore—the Yautja, an alien species driven by an honor-bound hunting culture. Dutch, among the earliest humans to confront a Predator, set the stage for numerous encounters that would follow.

In the original film, Dutch led a team of elite special forces operatives on a fateful jungle mission. Not only did he survive the terrifying hunt, but he also emerged victorious, slaying the alien creature. Given Schwarzenegger’s immense popularity during the late ’80s and early ’90s, it was anticipated that he would reprise his role in Predator 2. However, due to a salary dispute, he opted not to participate, a choice that would ultimately benefit the franchise more than his presence could have.

The Impact of Dutch’s Absence on the Franchise Evolution

Embracing Narrative Freedom in the Anthology Structure

By excluding Dutch’s character from Predator 2, the franchise evolved into an anthology series, allowing each installment to stand on its own. While certain elements—such as Yautja weaponry and hunting protocols—consistently recur, every film presents a fresh narrative featuring new protagonists and Predators. Although there are nods to the 1987 classic, each film develops its unique storytelling without being tethered to the events of its predecessors.

All Predator Franchise Movies
Movie	Release Date	RT Tomatometer Score	RT Popcornmeter Score
Predator	1987	80%	87%
Predator 2	1990	30%	44%
Alien vs. Predator	2004	22%	39%
Aliens vs. Predator: Requiem	2007	12%	30%
Predators	2010	65%	52%
The Predator	2018	34%	32%
Prey	2022	94%	74%
Predator: Badlands	2025	N/A	N/A
Prey 2	TBD	N/A	N/A

This narrative flexibility has proven beneficial, allowing each installment to approach the familiar theme of alien hunters differently. For instance, Predator 2 diverged from its predecessor by shifting the setting ten years later and relocating the iconic hunt to the urban landscape of Los Angeles. Subsequent films continued to innovate by exploring various environments and even territories beyond Earth.

The Franchise’s Challenges and Strengths

Discerning the Core Issues Within the Franchise

Despite a legacy spanning 35 years, the Predator franchise experienced few films that matched the caliber of the original. While some sequels and crossover events disappointed audiences, the anthology format was not the root cause of these shortcomings. Instead, the majority of these films, particularly Predator 2, suffered from well-known pitfalls common in action, horror, and sci-fi genres, including subpar scripts, disjointed editing, and one-dimensional characters.

Currently, Prey 2 is in the pipeline, and while plot specifics remain under wraps, its title hints at a potential direct sequel, distinguishing it from prior spinoffs such as the Alien vs. Predator series. This optimism was reignited by Dan Trachtenberg’s 2022 film, Prey, which reinvigorated interest in the franchise. Trachtenberg utilized the anthology model to its fullest by setting the film in the Comanche Nation 300 years ago, featuring a new type of primitive Predator. The Feral Predator engages in a gripping battle with Amber Midthunder’s Naru, a well-crafted protagonist whose journey culminates in a thrilling climax. Prey garnered critical acclaim and sparked further Predator-related projects.

The Promising Future of the Predator Franchise

Unbounded Narrative Potential Across Time and Space

The Berserker and Crucified Predators fighting in Predators (2010)

The success of Prey reestablished the franchise’s viability, demonstrating that tonal and thematic connections could exist with minimal reliance on prior films. This narrative independence allows directors like Trachtenberg—and those who follow—to explore various historical and futuristic contexts involving human characters, potentially leading to exceptional storylines similar to Prey.

While audiences have witnessed human protagonists transported to alien settings, the possibilities expand considerably across time and space. Envision a Yautja hunter encountering formidable warrior cultures throughout history, from battles in World War I trenches to the dramatic skirmishes of World War II’s Pacific Theater, or even ancient battlefields in the era of Spartans. Exploring such scenarios with skill could produce compelling additions to the franchise.

The Fate of Arnold Schwarzenegger’s Dutch Schaefer

Uncovering Dutch’s Potential Connections to Other Sci-Fi Lore

Following his harrowing encounter with the Predator, Dutch Schaefer emerges alive but not without consequences. The novelization of Predator 2 reveals that Dutch suffered radiation poisoning due to the self-destruct sequence initiated by the original Predator, which detonated after he mortally wounded it. Though he survived the blast, he was left severely affected and required hospitalization, leading to his eventual disappearance from the storyline.

Ending Dutch’s narrative after the original Predator allowed the franchise to pursue an expansive array of storytelling opportunities. Interestingly, a fan theory suggests a deeper connection between Dutch and another iconic sci-fi series. It proposes that he was offered a potential cure—transformation into a cyborg—which paved the way for him to become the prototype for the T-800 Terminator portrayed by Schwarzenegger in the Terminator franchise. Allegedly, the agencies of Cyberdyne and Skynet learned of Dutch through government files, leading to their interest in him as an experimental weapon.

This theory, while requiring considerable suspension of disbelief, creatively intertwines two beloved sci-fi franchises. Ultimately, Dutch Schaefer’s absence in Predator 2 not only proved beneficial for the franchise but also established a narrative landscape ripe with limitless possibilities.

Source & Images