Why Below Deck Sailing Yacht Season 5’s Efforts to Revive the Gary-Daisy-Colin Love Triangle Will Fall Flat

Below Deck Sailing Yacht season 5 has prompted mixed reactions among its dedicated audience. Many fans have noted a palpable absence of the usual tensions and confrontations that typically characterize the series. With the recent release of the mid-season trailer teasing yet another potential love triangle involving Daisy Kelliher and Gary King, some viewers express frustration over what seems like a rehash of previous storylines. Although Gary, Daisy, and Colin Macrae never truly engaged in a love triangle during the highly charged fourth season, the emotional stakes were undeniably high, particularly with Daisy’s choice to pursue Colin over Gary.

Daisy’s romantic journey took a turn in last season when her relationship with Colin, though initially promising, fizzled out before the reunion. This has left fans apprehensive about new romantic entanglements in season 5. As Daisy grapples with her complicated relationship with Gary and additional pressures aboard the Parsifal III, she seems to be on the cusp of a potentially positive twist. The trailer hints at a stirring moment between Daisy and Keith Allen, where their kiss ignites old flames of jealousy in Gary.

Hints of a Love Triangle in the Mid-Season Trailer

Daisy Enters Familiar Dynamics

The mid-season trailer suggests that Daisy may once again find herself embroiled in romantic complications reminiscent of season 4. It reveals a passionate kiss between Daisy and Keith, while Gary features in the background, seemingly struggling with envy. Having previously displayed dramatic jealousy regarding Daisy’s rapport with Colin, Gary’s feelings could be reigniting as he witnesses Daisy with someone new, leading to a case of serious déjà vu.

As the trailer continues to generate buzz around a budding romance between Daisy and Keith, one can’t help but wonder whether Gary will revert back to his jealous ways. Although their relationship dynamics appear to have shifted since season 4, Gary’s sense of possessiveness over Daisy still lingers. Should he navigate through these feelings, viewers may finally witness a reconciliation between the two that many have speculated about.

Reflecting on Season 4’s Dramatic Love Triangle

The Impact on Colin, Daisy, and Gary

Below Deck Sailing Yacht Season 5's Daisy Kelliher, Gary King, and Colin Macrae looking happy with colorful background — Image by Cesar Garcia

Despite not actively pursuing a romance, the dynamics among Daisy, Gary, and Colin became significantly challenging during season 4. Gary’s ongoing jealousy towards Colin strained both friendships, creating a rift that ultimately led to reduced communication. This discord escalated to a point where, during the reunion, both Gary and Daisy had to confront the fallout from their complicated ties.

Challenges in Recapturing Season 4’s Appeal

Repackaging the Love Triangle: A Lost Cause?

In the aftermath of season 4’s tumultuous conclusion, Gary and Daisy quickly realized they needed to navigate their complex emotions carefully. The drama surrounding the love triangle was nothing short of exhausting. As season 5 progresses, it appears the producers might be trying to rekindle similar magic by introducing jealousy and new crushes. However, it seems season 5 lacks the narrative depth required to make this work effectively. Rather than rehashing the same angles, the series would benefit from exploring fresh storylines that can engage viewers on a different level.

Below Deck Sailing Yacht broadcasts Mondays at 9 p.m. EST on Bravo.

Source: Below Deck/Instagram

Source & Images