Why It’s Too Late for Perfect Casting of Susan Pevensie in Narnia, But a Smaller Role Fits the Actor Better

The task of casting Netflix’s upcoming adaptation of The Chronicles of Narnia is no small feat. With a dedicated fan base and critics alike possessing strong preferences regarding the iconic characters, decisions will be scrutinized. A frequent name in fan casting discussions is Saoirse Ronan, known for her collaborations with director Greta Gerwig. While Ronan has previously denied rumors surrounding her involvement in this adaptation (as reported by Deadline), there remains a possibility for her participation, albeit as a different character than Susan Pevensie, for whom she was commonly considered.

Saoirse Ronan’s Potential Roles in Narnia

Greta Gerwig’s interpretation of Narnia will require a careful approach to the character of Susan, who often feels overlooked among the Pevensie siblings. While Ronan’s fair features and her established relationship with Gerwig could mark her as a fitting choice for Susan, the reality is that age and narrative constraints make this role infeasible. Furthermore, the world crafted by C.S. Lewis includes a variety of characters beyond the Pevensies, leaving ample opportunity for Ronan to shine in other roles.

Several characters across the Narnia series could potentially be brought to life by Ronan, whether in minor appearances or more prominent roles. While voice roles for animals are a possibility, many would prefer to see Ronan physically embody a character. One option could be the Pevensies’ mother, a role that, while minor, could still establish familial grounding early in the story.

Another potential character is Jadis, the formidable White Witch, infamously portrayed by Tilda Swinton. If Ronan were to tackle this role, she would undoubtedly rise to the occasion and create a lasting impression. Moreover, as the series progresses, she could portray Mrs. Lefay from The Magician’s Nephew, provided the story delves into her backstory. One of the most compelling and often underestimated antagonists is the Lady of the Green Kirtle from The Silver Chair — a character that could be a rich layer for Ronan to explore.

The Perfect Match: The Lady of the Green Kirtle

The Lady of the Green Kirtle presents a prime opportunity for Saoirse Ronan to flex her talents. Described as a primary antagonist in The Silver Chair, she is a captivating figure, characterized by her deception and malevolence. Ronan, known for embodying complex characters, has yet to fully embrace an outright villain role, making this a thrilling prospect for both her and audiences.

Interestingly, since fewer individuals are familiar with The Silver Chair than with The Lion, the Witch and the Wardrobe, Ronan’s portrayal of the Lady could introduce new audiences to a lesser-known aspect of the Narnia universe. Her ability to inject depth and complexity into seemingly simplistic characters could transform this blink-and-you-miss-it role into a highlight of the series, should her story be elaborated upon in the adaptation.

Honoring Fan Casting Through Strategic Role Selection

Including Ronan and other fan-favored actors in smaller roles would provide a nod to the fan community while allowing the narrative vision to take precedence. The Lady of the Green Kirtle, while significant, does not dominate the overall narrative, offering a balance between fan expectations and storytelling integrity. This could open avenues for Gerwig’s adaptation to flesh out the character’s complexities in a creative narrative context.

The Path Forward for Narnia and Ronan

For Saoirse Ronan to embody the Lady of the Green Kirtle, it hinges on Gerwig’s commitment to bringing the entire series to life. Currently, there are speculations about beginning the film journey with The Magician’s Nephew, yet this approach necessitates early studio support for the entire series. With The Silver Chair being the fourth book in order of release, a chronological approach could delay her anticipated role considerably.

Presently, Gerwig is confirmed to direct the first two installments of The Chronicles of Narnia. While the adaptation of The Silver Chair hasn’t been officially discussed, there’s potential for Ronan’s involvement through clever narrative integration in earlier films that establish the witches’ backgrounds. Although there remains uncertainty about Ronan’s participation, the mere consideration of her fitting into this universe illustrates the profound possibilities that lie ahead for the Narnia series.

Source & Images