Why Jay Halstead’s Return Could Harm Chicago PD, Despite Jesse Lee Soffer’s Desire to Rejoin

In the long-running series Chicago P.D., Detective Jay Halstead, portrayed by Jesse Lee Soffer, bid farewell to the show after nearly a decade with the Intelligence unit. Halstead’s emotional exit came following his confrontation with criminals involved in pharmacy robberies, leading Sergeant Hank Voight (Jason Beghe) and Detective Hailey Upton (Tracy Spiridakos) to cover for him. Ultimately, Halstead chose to leave Chicago, disillusioned by the constant deceptions and moral compromises of his work, seeking renewal and purpose through a return to military service.

His departure left a profound impact on both Hailey and the show’s fans, as Halstead was one of the most beloved characters in the ensemble. This pivotal moment has opened doors for the development of other story arcs within the Intelligence unit. Interestingly, Soffer has expressed a willingness to reprise his role as Halstead, suggesting a potential future comeback that would not disrupt his current involvement with FBI: International, another notable creation from Dick Wolf. However, such a return may not necessarily benefit the series’ narrative.

Jesse Lee Soffer Open to Returning as Jay Halstead in Chicago P.D.

A Chance for Halstead to Conclude His Narrative

Jay Halstead in his car while he is thinking in Chicago PD

Soffer’s willingness to step back into Halstead’s shoes offers fans hope, especially given the abrupt nature of his exit, which many found unsatisfying. A returning Halstead could provide a fitting conclusion to his storyline, perhaps by tackling a significant case or allowing for heartfelt goodbyes with his colleagues in Intelligence. While the option to kill off Halstead exists, fans overwhelmingly prefer a more uplifting narrative for the character.

Additionally, a comeback could facilitate a reunion between Halstead and Upton, who departed approximately a year after Halstead. Their relationship, central to the show’s narrative, could be reignited during a crossover event with both Chicago P.D. and the FBI series, wherein both actors could contribute their unique perspectives from both franchises.

It May Be Best If Jay Halstead Never Returns to Chicago P.D.

Halstead’s Journey Appears Complete

While the idea of Halstead’s return may delight viewers, it risks overshadowing the ongoing narratives currently at play, which involve the evolving dynamics within the team, such as Voight’s complicated relationship with Nina Chapman and Kim Burgess’s rise to detective. Halstead’s extensive story arc, interwoven with critical personal and professional relationships, has defined a significant part of the series. Reviving this storyline could be seen as regressive in light of new developments.

Moreover, Halstead’s departure was deeply motivated by a personal crisis, as he faced profound doubts about his identity and purpose. A reappearance would need to be meaningfully integrated into the overarching plot, rather than merely a ploy to capture ratings or exploit fan nostalgia since Upton’s departure further distances him from the unit’s progression.

Chicago P.D. Cannot Rectify Its Jay Halstead Decision

Halstead Must Confront His Own Imperfections

While a return could provide an avenue for Halstead to resolve unresolved issues, including reconnecting meaningfully with Hailey following their divorce, the complexities of his past actions—such as the choice he made to take lethal action in his last case—cannot be overlooked. These moments have left indelible marks on his psyche, akin to those faced by Voight and his colleagues.

Several characters have exited the show only to return after pursuing other projects, reflecting the fluid nature of series roles. Ultimately, Halstead’s return rests on Soffer’s willingness and on whether both he and the creators believe his narrative warrants a revival or if it has reached its natural conclusion.

Viewers can expect Chicago P.D. Season 12 to return with the ninth episode on Wednesday, January 8, 2025, at 10 PM ET on NBC.

Source & Images