Why Sonic The Hedgehog 3 Must Not Repeat James Marsden’s $1.1 Billion Trilogy Mistakes

As Paramount Pictures gears up for the release of Sonic the Hedgehog 3, there is an urgent need to steer clear of the pitfalls that plagued James Marsden’s previous franchise, which, despite grossing an impressive $1.1 billion, ended on a disheartening note. In the realm of video game film adaptations, the Sonic movies have emerged as notable successes in recent years. While critical reviews may not always shine, the fan reception remains overwhelmingly positive, driving audiences to theaters in droves.

The excitement for the third chapter is palpable, particularly with the return of the beloved cast, and the addition of Keanu Reeves as the iconic character Shadow. Marsden is set to reprise his role as Tom Wachowski, a character crafted specifically for the films, inspiring mixed opinions among fans. While there is thrill surrounding the cinematic premiere of the third installment, it risks jeopardizing the franchise’s future if it mirrors the ending of Marsden’s earlier trilogy.

James Marsden’s X-Men Trilogy: A Disappointing Conclusion

A Significant Decline in Reception: Sequel vs. Threequel

James Marsden’s history in blockbuster films is a mixed bag, yet his portrayal of Cyclops in the X-Men trilogy stands out. While these films are now considered pivotal in the superhero genre, the critical reception varied significantly. The first two installments achieved Certified Fresh status on Rotten Tomatoes, with the sequel scoring slightly higher than its predecessor.

Movie	Tomatometer	Audience Score	Budget ($)	Box Office Gross ($)
X-Men (2000)	82%	83%	296 million	75 million
X2 (2003)	85%	85%	407.7 million	110 million
X-Men: The Last Stand (2006)	56%	61%	460 million	210 million

Regrettably, the third installment suffered a stark decline, with the Tomatometer plunging by 29% and the audience score dropping by 24%. Additionally, box office performance did not keep pace with its predecessors; while the first two films grossed nearly four times their budgets, The Last Stand managed just double its production costs. As the first two Sonic films exhibited parallel trends in audience and critical reception, Sonic the Hedgehog 3 must seek a different trajectory from the X-Men trilogy’s descent into mediocrity.

Sonic The Hedgehog 3 and the Risk of Negative Reception

A Different Outcome is Crucial for Sonic

Unlike the X-Men trilogy, the Sonic films have enjoyed a more favorable audience reception compared to critical responses, giving greater weight to viewer ratings. However, a significant decline in audience scores for Sonic the Hedgehog 3 could jeopardize the future of the franchise. The film is expected to have a considerably lower budget than The Last Stand, suggesting that the potential for a fourth installment may rely more on a favorable budget-to-revenue ratio rather than on critical ratings.

Source & Images