Why Star Wars Fans Dislike Jar Jar Binks: The Unseen Best Moment That Was Cut from the Film

Jar Jar Binks remains one of the most reviled characters in the Star Wars universe—not for villainous deeds, but for his overwhelming annoyance factor among fans. However, insights from recent comic adaptations suggest that had a pivotal scene been included in the films, public perception of Jar Jar might be significantly different.

The recent release of Star Wars: The Phantom Menace 25th Anniversary Special by Greg Pak and Will Sliney provides a fresh perspective on the original movie, featuring additional scenes that give deeper context to significant moments. Among these additions are Anakin Skywalker’s prophetic vision of becoming a Jedi, an encounter where he saves a Tusken Raider, and a heartfelt exchange between him and Jar Jar Binks following Anakin’s first meeting with the Jedi Council.

Comic panel showcasing a scene with Jar Jar

In this pivotal scene, Anakin, alone and disheartened in the Jedi Temple after learning that the Council has refused to allow Qui-Gon Jinn to train him, meets Jar Jar Binks. Rather than indulging in chaotic antics, Jar Jar displays unexpected depth. He empathizes with Anakin’s feelings of being overlooked and reassures him about his good heart, offering a glimpse of hope.

Reevaluating Jar Jar Binks: A Need for Serious Consideration

Moving Beyond Comedic Expectations

Jar Jar Binks standing in the desert, smiling with a thumbs up and his tongue sticking out.

Initially introduced as a source of comedy, Jar Jar Binks often succeeded only in irritating viewers. His clumsiness led to mishaps in nearly every scene, even during critical moments that demanded tension. This relentless triviality frustrated many in the audience, contributing to a general disdain for his character.

This recent comic scene showcases that Jar Jar possesses the potential for sincere characterization—an aspect that might have redefined his role had it made it to the original film. Had audiences seen this more profound dynamic with Anakin, it could have transformed the narrative and lent greater significance to their relationship.

Can One Scene Truly Redeem Jar Jar Binks?

Complexity Behind the Disdain for Jar Jar Binks

Jar Jar Binks speaking to the galactic senate in Star Wars.

Although Jar Jar’s moment of compassion towards Anakin enriches his character, it may not suffice to fully redeem him in the eyes of many fans. As the prequel trilogy progressed, Jar Jar transitioned into a political figure, acquiring influence as a representative of the Gungans. This culminated in his role in the Galactic Senate, where he inadvertently facilitated catastrophic political maneuvers, such as the extension of the Emergency Powers Act that ultimately allowed Palpatine’s ascent to dictatorship.

While Jar Jar’s clumsiness did not single-handedly dismantle the Republic, his actions contributed to the rise of the Empire. Thus, while a touching interaction with Anakin might alleviate some of the frustration surrounding his character, it cannot erase the broader historical repercussions associated with his political involvement. Ultimately, the core grievance remains rooted in Jar Jar’s perceived annoyance—a quality that, to some extent, might be alleviated by this reimagined characterization.

Source & Images