Why the Below Deck Franchise Should Launch a New Spinoff: Impact of Below Deck Sailing Yacht on the Network

The recent season of Below Deck Sailing Yacht has left many fans feeling uninspired, raising concerns about the need for Bravo to innovate the franchise. Since its inception in 2013, the Below Deck series has undergone various transformations, expanding to include several spin-offs. Notably, in 2020, the network introduced Below Deck Sailing Yacht, featuring the charismatic Captain Glenn Shephard aboard a stunning 54-meter sailing yacht. The show distinguished itself with a younger cast exploring beautiful locations: Season 1 took place in Greece, followed by Croatia in Season 2, Spain in Season 3, Italy in Season 4, and Ibiza in Season 5.

Initially, I found the first few seasons of Below Deck Sailing Yacht captivating due to their distinct vibe compared to the original Below Deck and Below Deck Mediterranean. Key cast members like Colin Macrae, Daisy Kelliher, and Gary King regularly joined Captain Glenn on the Parsifal III, contributing to compelling storylines. Seasons 1 to 3 were packed with unexpected twists and engaging moments that helped viewers form connections with the crew. However, my enthusiasm waned significantly during Season 4, and Season 5 further underscored why this spin-off has lost its appeal.

The Impact of Gary King on the Franchise

Gary’s Continuous Presence

Despite initially capturing the audience’s attention, the show’s ratings began to decline, primarily due to Gary’s evolving role. He first charmed viewers as the first officer in Season 2, showcasing a blend of impressive sailing skills and a charming personality. I appreciated his camaraderie with cast members like Colin and Daisy, which set them apart from the usual fare. Yet, as the seasons progressed, Gary’s reputation suffered dramatically due to his increasingly desperate attempts at romance with various female crew members, including Mads Herrera and Anna Zhou.

In Season 4, Gary’s behavior shifted from merely eager to outright off-putting, entangling himself in two love triangles involving Chief Stew Daisy and Junior Stew Mads. This not only strained his friendships with Colin and Daisy but also alienated viewers. His fall from favor culminated when allegations of sexual misconduct surfaced, claiming he attempted to force himself on a makeup artist. Surprisingly, despite the severity of these accusations, Bravo chose to retain Gary for Season 5, a decision that disillusioned many loyal fans.

Revitalizing the Franchise with a New Spin-Off

The Potential of Reformed Spin-Offs

Although I don’t advocate for the cancellation of Below Deck Sailing Yacht, I believe significant changes are imperative to rekindle viewer interest. This includes onboarding a new crew composed of more engaging personalities than Gary. If Bravo remains unable to refresh the cast, launching another spin-off may be the best solution. Such a move would not only attract renewed attention but also enhance the franchise’s visibility on social media, potentially luring back former fans.

Bravo’s Below Deck Down Under exemplifies how a fresh spin-off can reignite viewer enthusiasm. When I watched it for the first time in 2022, Captain Jason Chambers brought an exhilarating energy, showcasing a unique blend of youthfulness and charm. His approach added an intriguing dimension to the show while maintaining the overall concept. If Bravo were to consider another spin-off akin to Below Deck Down Under, it could undoubtedly rejuvenate viewer interest in the entire franchise.

Exploring Potential New Spin-Offs in the Below Deck Franchise

Celebrity Integration for Better Viewership

Below Deck Sailing Yacht’s current dullness stems from the controversies surrounding Gary and a noticeable decline in originality. Meanwhile, both the original Below Deck and Below Deck Mediterranean have failed to evolve meaningfully over time.

To reinvigorate the franchise, Bravo should consider crafting a spin-off that distinguishes itself from prior shows. For instance, incorporating celebrity guests and popular reality TV personalities in each episode could provide a refreshing twist. Additionally, focusing on smaller vessels in more relatable environments could replace Below Deck Sailing Yacht’s current format.

Below Deck Sailing Yacht continues to air Mondays at 9 p.m. EST on Bravo.

Sources: Bravo/YouTube, Below Deck/Instagram

Source & Images