Why The Next Big Zelda Game on Switch 2 Should Not Be a Direct Sequel to Tears of the Kingdom

With the highly anticipated launch of the Switch 2 on the horizon, fans of The Legend of Zelda are eager to discover what Nintendo has planned for this iconic franchise. The success of major 3D titles like Breath of the Wild and its sequel, Tears of the Kingdom, has raised the bar for future installments. However, despite the popularity of these games, expectations are mounting for Nintendo to deliver innovative and groundbreaking experiences on the forthcoming console.

The Case Against a TOTK Sequel

It’s tempting to envision a direct sequel to Tears of the Kingdom as a strategy for easing players into the new console, capitalizing on the familiarity of its predecessor. Both Tears of the Kingdom and Breath of the Wild have achieved remarkable sales and acclaim, making the idea of a sequel appealing. However, pursuing this avenue might constrain the potential of the next 3D Zelda entry, limiting its ability to chart bold new directions.

The Uniqueness of the Zelda Franchise

In the Zelda series, the development of direct sequels is a rarity. Each title typically strives to carve out its unique identity. For example, Majora’s Mask was a sequel to Ocarina of Time but relied heavily on its predecessor’s engine to explore different gameplay dynamics creatively. Likewise, Tears of the Kingdom began as additional downloadable content for Breath of the Wild before evolving into a standalone adventure, as noted by Kotaku.

Despite this, it is important to recognize that both entries in this renowned franchise have been highly innovative and engaging. Tears of the Kingdom enhances the templates laid by its forerunner while introducing ambitious narratives and intricate mechanics that significantly enrich the experience of exploring a vast Hyrule.

The Need for Originality in Switch 2 Titles

As we look toward the possible launch of the Switch 2, there is a compelling case for developing an entirely original 3D Zelda game. With anticipation surrounding the enhanced features of the Switch 2, players expect a range of games that will showcase the console’s greater power and capabilities, delivering imaginative experiences that were previously unimaginable.

Next-Gen Expectations

The Zelda franchise has a rich history of demonstrating the full potential of Nintendo’s hardware. A prime illustration is Skyward Sword, which skillfully utilized the motion controls of the Wii to elevate combat. Similarly, Breath of the Wild benefited from the capabilities of both the Wii U and Switch, pioneering a fresh direction for the series that emphasized vast exploration and player agency.

Original entries empower the developers to explore the limits of Nintendo’s technology while simultaneously shaping the franchise’s future. A sequel to Tears of the Kingdom risks stagnating innovation, as players may perceive it as a rehash rather than an exploration of the new possibilities the Switch 2 offers. To maintain momentum and enthusiasm for the franchise, Nintendo will need to ensure that the next major installment distinguishes itself with fresh ideas and ambitious gameplay.

Maintaining Classic Elements

While pushing the envelope is essential for Zelda’s evolution, it remains crucial to honor the franchise’s classic elements. Many fans cherish the traditional Zelda gameplay that relies on established mechanics. Balancing innovative titles with those that embrace the beloved Zelda formula is vital for sustaining the series’ legacy and catering to diverse player preferences.

Nintendo’s Commitment to the Series

Zelda In Zelda Echoes Of Wisdom with Ganon — Custom Image by Katarina Cimbaljevic.

Fortunately, Nintendo has been proactive in ensuring the preservation of classic Zelda experiences. The latest addition, Echoes of Wisdom, integrates traditional gameplay mechanics with novel concepts to create an engaging 2D adventure. Furthermore, remasters and remakes of classic titles on the Switch ensure that fans can always access some of the most iconic entries in the franchise.

Nevertheless, the key concern as we transition into the era of the Switch 2 lies in how the next major 3D entry will enhance the Zelda series. While a sequel to Tears of the Kingdom offers a refreshing perspective, it may not fulfill the ambition that players desire. If The Legend of Zelda is to maintain its stature and continue thriving in Nintendo’s new chapter, the next installment must boldly break new ground for the franchise.

Sources: Nintendo , Kotaku

Source & Images