Winston’s Ballerina Role Casts Doubt on Long-Standing Theory of Him Being John Wick’s Father

Winston Scott’s confirmation as a mentor and father figure in the upcoming spinoff film, From the World of John Wick: Ballerina, significantly diminishes the likelihood of a popular fan theory suggesting he might be John Wick’s biological father. Set for release on June 6, 2025, this film holds the distinction of being the first entry in the John Wick cinematic universe outside the main series, featuring Ana de Armas as Eve Macarro—a ballerina being trained as an assassin by the Ruska Roma.

The cast of Ballerina sees the inclusion of new talents like Gabriel Byrne and Norman Reedus, alongside familiar faces from previous installments. Anjelica Huston will play a significant role as The Director, Keanu Reeves will make a cameo as John Wick, and the late Lance Reddick will reprise his final performance as Charon. Notably, Ian McShane will return as Winston Scott, the owner of the New York Continental. This casting choice casts doubt on the previously speculated theory regarding his deeper connection to John Wick.

Winston’s Relationship With Eve Echoes His Bond With John Wick

A Father Figure to Eve, Much Like to John

Winston looking surprised in John Wick 3

Marquis confronts Winston in John Wick Chapter 4

In a recent interview, Ian McShane offered insight into Winston’s dynamic with Eve in the forthcoming film. He revealed that Winston has “met her before” and acknowledged a relationship with her parents, indicating that he has known her since childhood. Additionally, McShane suggested that Winston has monitored Eve’s progress over the years and is poised to assist her at pivotal moments in her journey. This relationship casts Winston in the role of a distant father figure, much like his bond with John Wick.

While Winston’s mentorship of John has always been hinted at, this newfound connection to Eve appears to dilute the uniqueness of John’s storyline. If Winston has extended this kind of paternal guidance to others, it suggests that his bond with John may not be as special as previously thought.

Winston’s Role in Ballerina Diminishes the Father Theory

Winston As A Paternal Figure Rather Than A Biological Father

Ana de Armas as Eve walking through a nightclub in Ballerina

Winston’s consistent watch over John, juxtaposed with John’s parentage remaining ambiguous, fed into the fan theory that Winston could be John’s biological father. However, his mentorship extends to Eve as well, leading to a reinterpretation of Winston’s character. This portrayal suggests that Winston is not John’s father but rather a guiding paternal figure who looks after various young assassins. His instinct to nurture young contract killers illustrates a broader, more fatherly role rather than a singular connection with John Wick.

Both John and Eve have origins tied to the Ruska Roma, which raises the possibility that Winston has had extensive interactions with this group, further explaining his protective nature toward their members. It’s plausible that Winston has forged similar relationships with other young assassins, making his dynamic with John less exclusive and more a part of his inherent character traits.

The Appeal of Winston as John Wick’s Biological Father

A Sweet and Logical Theory

John talking to Winston in John Wick Chapter 4

The prospect of Winston being John Wick’s father is intriguing and resonated strongly with fans, contributing to the depth of their relationship. Among John’s closest allies such as Charon, Sofia, and the Bowery King, Winston’s emotional investment is particularly profound. He consistently supports John and goes to great lengths to ensure his survival. The lack of clarity surrounding Winston’s motivations has led many to believe that a father-son relationship could explain this profound bond.

Since Ballerina is set between John Wick: Chapter 3 – Parabellum and John Wick: Chapter 4, it adds a new layer to Winston’s established character. While some aspects of the John Wick universe thrive on mystery, the connection between Winston and John prompts a need for clarification. Unfortunately, with the new revelations in Ballerina, it seems increasingly unlikely that the true depth of their relationship is rooted in fatherhood.

Source & Images