Would Rhysand Have Prevented Feyre and Tamlin’s Wedding in ACOTAR Without Her Request for Help? A Complex Discussion

In the enchanting realm of A Court of Thorns & Roses, Feyre and Rhysand ultimately emerge as the central couple. However, the journey is far from straightforward, especially during the series’ second book. Though Feyre begins an engagement with Tamlin in the first installment, the sequel, A Court of Mist and Fury, shifts this narrative dramatically. A pivotal moment occurs when Rhysand disrupts Feyre’s wedding, initiating a journey that allows their relationship to flourish during her time in the Night Court. This begs the intriguing question: what if Feyre had not silently reached out for help right before her wedding?

It is conceivable that Rhysand would have intervened during the wedding ceremony in ACOMAF, particularly given his deep understanding of Feyre and his disdain for Tamlin. However, this speculation ignites a deeper analysis of his character. Rhysand has exhibited a willingness to let Feyre make her own decisions, at least in the initial stages. The profound mental connection they share early in A Court of Mist and Fury ensures that we may never fully explore alternative outcomes. Nonetheless, considering the intricacies of Rhysand’s character adds layers to this ongoing debate.

Rhysand Had Strong Justifications for Interrupting the Wedding

A Court of Mist and Fury Cover with a blue background and Feyre's torso in armor

Rhysand’s decision to halt Feyre’s wedding is significantly influenced by his awareness of their bond; he understands that she’s his mate long before that moment. Their shared experiences, particularly when they were Under the Mountain, have already fostered a connection. While the existence of a mate bond doesn’t necessitate a romantic relationship within the ACOTAR universe, it is improbable that Rhysand would allow Feyre to wed without revealing their deep connection. Furthermore, Rhysand recognizes that Feyre requires assistance, knowing that Tamlin has not been treating her with the care she deserves.

Before Feyre feels overwhelmed at the altar, Rhysand is already aware of the turmoil in her life. He senses her struggles with PTSD and the nightmares haunting her, which Tamlin seems oblivious to. In ACOMAF, Rhysand openly acknowledges this concern, providing him ample justification to intervene — whether she called out for help or not. In recognizing her pain, he understands that he must act, especially given their tumultuous past with Tamlin that complicates matters significantly.

The Sole Reason Rhysand Might Have Allowed the Wedding

The only conceivable reason Rhysand might have allowed Feyre to proceed with her marriage to Tamlin in ACOMAF is his deep respect for her autonomy. Once Feyre and Rhysand’s relationship develops, it becomes evident that they operate with mutual trust — even if it sometimes involves risky choices. Rhysand’s commitment to Feyre’s well-being would prevent him from exacerbating her emotional state, particularly if she still desired the marriage.

However, during that critical moment, Feyre lacked key information regarding her connection with Rhysand, specifically that he was her destined mate. This absence of knowledge could have influenced Rhysand’s decision, leading him to believe Feyre deserved clarity about her options. Moreover, Rhysand’s questionable decisions in A Court of Silver Flames further complicate this argument, as he withholds vital information from Feyre, raising concerns regarding the health of their dynamic.

Ultimately, while we may never know how events would play out had Feyre not called for help, it appears likely that Rhysand would have intervened one way or another. He would likely strive to ensure Feyre was in a better mental state to make such an impactful decision and would want her to be informed about the mating bond. Fortunately, Feyre’s plea makes Rhysand’s choice to interrupt her wedding a much simpler decision.

Source & Images